Micro-Semiauto vs. Snubbie Revolver (concealed carry)

Published on November 2, 2012
Duration: 4:35

This video compares a Springfield Armory XDS micro-semi-auto pistol with a .357 Magnum snubnose revolver for concealed carry. The instructor discusses factors like size, capacity, power, controllability, and carry comfort, concluding that while the revolver may offer more power and proven reliability, the choice depends on individual priorities and perceived threats. The discussion aims to gather audience opinions on which platform is preferred for concealed carry.

Quick Summary

When choosing between a micro-semi-auto and a snubnose revolver for concealed carry, consider size, capacity, power, and reliability. While semi-autos often have higher capacity, a .357 Magnum revolver can be equally small and more powerful. Experienced carriers can mitigate revolver cylinder width, and sight quality is generally better on semi-autos, though less critical in close-quarters.

Chapters

  1. 00:12Introduction: The Question
  2. 00:20Springfield Armory XDS Purchase
  3. 00:24Semi-Auto vs. Revolver Dilemma
  4. 00:55Hype of Tiny Semi-Autos
  5. 01:07Revolver Size and Power Comparison
  6. 01:37Carry Advantage: Cylinder Width
  7. 01:42Weight and Material Comparison
  8. 01:48Lightweight Revolver Options
  9. 02:03Reasons to Carry a Semi-Auto
  10. 02:13Sight Quality Comparison
  11. 02:34Capacity Advantage: Semi-Auto vs Revolver
  12. 02:54Which is the Better Carry Choice?
  13. 03:03Collector's Items and Carry Risk
  14. 03:22Multiple Reasons for Choice
  15. 03:48Audience Opinion: What Matters Most?
  16. 04:09Conclusion: Your Choice and Why

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main considerations when choosing between a micro-semi-auto and a snubnose revolver for concealed carry?

Key factors include size, capacity, power, controllability, sight quality, trigger type, and the proven reliability of revolvers. While semi-autos often offer higher capacity, revolvers can provide more power in a similarly sized package and are known for their reliability.

Can a snubnose revolver be effectively concealed despite its cylinder width?

Yes, experienced revolver carriers can often overcome the cylinder's width by utilizing the contours of their body. The perceived carry advantage of slim semi-automatics over revolvers may be less significant than commonly believed.

Are small semi-automatic pistols always more powerful than snubnose revolvers?

Not necessarily. A .357 Magnum snubnose revolver can be as small as, or even smaller than, a micro-semi-automatic like the Springfield XDS (.45 ACP) and deliver more controllable energy, challenging the assumption that small semi-autos inherently hold a power advantage.

What are the potential drawbacks of carrying a valuable or rare firearm for concealed carry?

Carrying a collector's item or a hard-to-replace firearm for concealed carry poses a significant risk. If the firearm is confiscated or damaged, it could be nearly impossible to replace, making more common firearms a safer choice for daily carry.

Related News

All News →

More EDC & Lifestyle Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →