1860 Henry Reproductions: Italian vs American

Published on November 4, 2019
Duration: 20:49

This comprehensive review compares the Italian-made Uberti and American-made Henry Repeating Arms reproductions of the 1860 Henry rifle. Expert analysis covers aesthetic differences, out-of-the-box accuracy at 50 yards, internal mechanical comparisons (MIM vs. machined parts), and the potential for aftermarket modifications like lifter upgrades for increased capacity. The assessment highlights the strengths of each model, guiding viewers on which rifle best suits heirloom quality versus practical, modifiable use.

Quick Summary

The Henry USA 1860 Reproduction offers superior fit, finish, and out-of-the-box accuracy (4-inch group at 50 yards) for heirloom quality, priced at $2,415.00. The Uberti 1860 Reproduction, at $1,499.00, is a reliable, budget-friendly option adaptable for historical 15+1 capacity modifications.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Aesthetic Comparison
  2. 03:26First Shooting Test (50 Yards)
  3. 07:18Second Shooting Test & Accuracy Results
  4. 10:52Internal Mechanics & Toggle Links
  5. 13:15Lifter Conversion & Capacity
  6. 15:36Final Assessment & MSRP

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the Uberti and Henry USA 1860 Henry reproductions?

The Henry USA model boasts superior fit and finish with near-invisible seams and a mirror-like brass receiver, offering excellent out-of-the-box accuracy. The Uberti is a reliable workhorse, more budget-friendly, and readily adaptable for historical capacity modifications using aftermarket parts.

How does the accuracy of the Uberti and Henry USA 1860 Henry reproductions compare?

In testing at 50 yards, the Henry USA achieved a 4-inch group initially, tightening to 3.5 inches, while the Uberti produced a 4.5-inch group that remained consistent. The Henry USA required no sight adjustments, whereas the Uberti needed manual front sight filing.

Can the capacity of these 1860 Henry reproductions be increased?

Yes, the Uberti 1860 Reproduction can be modified with aftermarket lifters from sources like The Smith Shop to achieve the original 15+1 round capacity, often using .45 Cowboy Special. The Henry USA model is not directly compatible with this specific modification.

Which 1860 Henry reproduction is better for historical accuracy versus heirloom quality?

For historical reenactors or those prioritizing original capacity and a more traditional feel, the Uberti is often preferred due to its modification potential and lower cost. For a premium heirloom piece with exceptional fit, finish, and accuracy, the Henry USA is the superior choice.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from InRangeTV

View all →