1911 vs M1 Carbine in a Practical Match

Published on June 27, 2020
Duration: 9:26

A practical match comparing the 1911 pistol and the M1 Carbine demonstrated the carbine's superior effectiveness, fulfilling its design purpose. The M1 Carbine consistently outperformed the 1911 in speed and score across various stages, including Mozambique drills, falling plates, and plate racks. Despite historical reputations for reliability issues, the carbine proved faster and easier to aim, significantly reducing engagement times.

Quick Summary

The M1 Carbine proved more effective than the 1911 pistol in a practical shooting match, scoring 64 to the 1911's 54. The carbine was consistently faster and easier to aim, fulfilling its design purpose of providing auxiliary troops with a superior weapon.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: 1911 vs M1 Carbine
  2. 01:24Stage 1: Mozambique Drill Comparison
  3. 03:13Stage 2: Falling Plates Challenge
  4. 04:59Stage 3: Static Targets & Movement
  5. 06:38Stage 4: Plate Rack Showdown
  6. 08:30Conclusion: M1 Carbine vs 1911 Results

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the purpose of the M1 Carbine compared to the 1911 pistol?

The M1 Carbine was designed to provide auxiliary troops, like drivers and engineers, with a more effective weapon than the 1911 pistol, which was found to be less effective at range and harder to shoot accurately.

How did the M1 Carbine perform against the 1911 in a Mozambique drill?

The M1 Carbine was significantly faster, completing the drill in 5 seconds with a score of 13, compared to the 1911's 7 seconds and score of 11. The carbine was noted as much easier and faster to aim.

What were the final scores of the 1911 vs M1 Carbine practical match?

The M1 Carbine achieved a final score of 64, while the 1911 pistol scored 54. This result confirmed the carbine's superior practical effectiveness as intended by its design.

Are there any known reliability issues with the 1911 or M1 Carbine?

Both firearms have historical reputations for reliability issues. During this test, a magazine malfunction occurred with the M1 Carbine, though it did not detract from its overall performance advantage.

Related News

All News →

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →