22 Magnum: Walther vs. Smith & Wesson

Published on October 25, 2023
Duration: 18:20

This video provides a head-to-head comparison of the Walther and Smith & Wesson 22 Magnum semi-automatic pistols. The reviewer, an experienced firearms instructor, highlights key differences in magazine capacity, ergonomics, safety features, and accuracy. Both firearms demonstrated excellent reliability and accuracy during testing, making the final choice dependent on personal preference and value.

Quick Summary

The Walther and Smith & Wesson 22 Magnum pistols were compared for magazine capacity, ergonomics, and accuracy. The S&W boasts a 30-round magazine versus the Walther's 15-round capacity, and includes an ambidextrous safety. Both firearms proved highly reliable with minimal accuracy differences at 15 yards.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Walther vs. Smith & Wesson 22 Magnum
  2. 00:24Outdoor Range Conditions and Setup
  3. 01:06Comparing New 22 Magnum Semi-Automatic Pistols
  4. 01:36Brand Reputation: Walther and Smith & Wesson
  5. 03:17Magazine Capacity: Walther (15rd) vs. S&W (30rd)
  6. 04:45Walther 22 Magnum: Ergonomics and Controls
  7. 05:52Shooting the Walther 22 Magnum
  8. 06:51Smith & Wesson 22 Magnum: Magazine Loading
  9. 07:42Smith & Wesson 22 Magnum: Controls and Safety
  10. 08:30Smith & Wesson 22 Magnum: Sights and Accuracy
  11. 09:4830 Rounds of Shooting: S&W M&P
  12. 10:32Walther 22 Magnum: Second Magazine Test
  13. 10:59Walther Feel and Sight Alignment
  14. 11:42Accuracy Test Setup: 15 Yards
  15. 12:27Walther 10-Round Accuracy Test
  16. 13:41Walther Magazine Drop Free
  17. 13:46Smith & Wesson 10-Round Accuracy Test
  18. 15:32Wrap-up: Key Differences and Conclusion
  19. 16:07Measured Group Sizes: Walther vs. S&W
  20. 17:06Final Recommendation: Which 22 Magnum is Right?

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between the Walther and Smith & Wesson 22 Magnum pistols?

The primary differences lie in magazine capacity, with the Walther holding 15 rounds and the Smith & Wesson holding 30 rounds. The S&W also features an ambidextrous manual safety, while the Walther has a more minimalist control layout with ambidextrous slide release and magazine release.

How did the accuracy of the Walther and Smith & Wesson 22 Magnum pistols compare?

Accuracy was very close. The Smith & Wesson M&P produced a 1.76-inch group at 15 yards, while the Walther achieved a 2.08-inch group. The reviewer considered these results to be within the margin of user error for offhand shooting.

Which 22 Magnum pistol is more reliable?

Both the Walther and Smith & Wesson 22 Magnum pistols demonstrated exceptional reliability during testing, with the reviewer reporting zero malfunctions with either firearm, even when using the 30-round magazine in the S&W.

What is the price difference between the Walther and Smith & Wesson 22 Magnum pistols?

The Smith & Wesson M&P 22 Magnum is approximately $100 more expensive than the Walther 22 Magnum. This price difference is weighed against the S&W's significantly higher magazine capacity.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Justin Opinion

View all →