45ACP Luger VS Spinner Target

Published on April 3, 2018
Duration: 18:46

This video details a challenge to test if the larger .45 ACP cartridge offers an advantage over 9mm Parabellum when engaging a difficult spinner target. The hosts compare a high-end Lugerman .45 ACP Luger reproduction against a vintage 9mm P08 Luger, highlighting historical context and the impact of bullet mass on target rotation. The .45 ACP demonstrated a clear advantage due to its greater momentum, confirming the effectiveness of heavier rounds for this specific challenge.

Quick Summary

The .45 ACP cartridge offers a significant advantage for spinning a heavy steel target due to its greater bullet mass and momentum compared to the 9mm Parabellum. This increased force helps ensure the target completes its full rotation more reliably, as demonstrated in tests comparing a Lugerman .45 ACP Luger reproduction with a 9mm Luger.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: The Spinner Challenge
  2. 01:31History: .45 ACP Luger in US Trials
  3. 03:31Lugerman .45 ACP Reproduction & Ammo Sensitivity
  4. 05:36Shooting Trials: .45 ACP vs 9mm Luger
  5. 09:20The Trommel Drum Magazine Explained
  6. 13:15Conclusion: Mass, Momentum, and Target Spin

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the .45 ACP cartridge make it easier to hit a spinner target?

Yes, the .45 ACP cartridge's greater bullet mass and momentum provide a distinct advantage in rotating a heavy steel spinner target compared to the 9mm Parabellum. This increased momentum helps ensure the target completes its 360-degree rotation more reliably.

What is the Lugerman .45 ACP Luger reproduction?

The Lugerman .45 ACP Luger is a high-end, modern reproduction of the Luger pistol chambered in .45 ACP, based on original 1907 blueprints. It features design modifications like a 55.5-degree grip angle to enhance feeding reliability with the larger caliber rounds and starts at a price of $5,800.

Why are Luger pistols sensitive to ammunition?

Luger pistols are known for their sensitivity to ammunition quality due to their intricate design and precise tolerances. Variations in bullet diameter, case dimensions, or powder charge can lead to feeding, extraction, or ignition malfunctions, especially with older or reproduction models.

What is the Trommel drum magazine for a Luger?

The Trommel drum magazine, also known as a 'snail' magazine, is a high-capacity (typically 32 rounds) accessory designed for Luger pistols, particularly the Artillery model, and was also used with the MP18 submachine gun. It requires a specialized loading tool due to its complex internal mechanism.

More from InRangeTV

View all →