Are Revolvers Obsolete?

Published on June 12, 2024
Duration: 11:42

This video from Honest Outlaw critically examines the relevance of revolvers in modern firearms use. While acknowledging their mechanical reliability and suitability for specific concealed carry scenarios (like grappling or firing through clothing), the video highlights their limitations. These include a higher bore axis contributing to felt recoil, the difficulty of mastering a double-action trigger, and a lack of accessory mounting options on many models. The expert reviewer suggests revolvers are not obsolete but rather niche tools for specific applications.

Quick Summary

Revolvers remain relevant for concealed carry and home defense, offering mechanical reliability and unique advantages in close-quarters combat or when fired through clothing. However, they present challenges like a higher bore axis causing more recoil and a difficult double-action trigger. Expert analysis suggests Kydex holsters enhance safety by protecting the trigger guard.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Are Revolvers Obsolete?
  2. 00:35Revolver Types and Sizes (Ruger LCR, Colt Python)
  3. 01:30Reliability and Malfunctions (Trigger Issues)
  4. 02:40Maintenance Requirements for Revolvers
  5. 03:45Ease of Use, Safety, and Holsters (Kydex vs. Leather)
  6. 05:13Recoil and Bore Axis in Revolvers
  7. 06:49Revolvers for Concealed Carry (Grappling, Clothing)
  8. 08:55Revolvers for Home Defense (S&W 686)
  9. 10:25Single Action Revolvers and Obsoletion
  10. 10:15Korth NXS 8 Shot Revolver Display

Frequently Asked Questions

Can revolvers still be considered reliable in modern self-defense scenarios?

Yes, revolvers maintain a reputation for mechanical reliability, especially in niche situations like extreme close-quarters combat or when fired through clothing. However, they are not immune to malfunctions, particularly those caused by user error like improper trigger manipulation.

What are the main disadvantages of revolvers compared to semi-automatic pistols?

Key disadvantages include a higher bore axis leading to more felt recoil, the difficulty of mastering the double-action trigger, and a general lack of accessory mounting options for lights or optics on many models.

Are Kydex holsters safer than leather for carrying revolvers?

The video suggests Kydex holsters are safer for concealed carry because their rigidity helps prevent the trigger from being accidentally depressed by external objects or during movement, unlike softer leather holsters.

Why might a revolver be preferred for concealed carry in specific situations?

Revolvers can be advantageous for concealed carry during grappling or when the firearm might be pressed against clothing, as they are less likely to jam or experience malfunctions in these scenarios compared to semi-automatic pistols.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Honest Outlaw

View all →