Battle of the 5.7s: Which is better?

Published on October 22, 2024
Duration: 9:49

This video compares three 5.7x28mm pistols: the Tisas PX 57, Smith & Wesson M&P 57, and Ruger 57. It details their specifications, trigger feel, ergonomics, and price points, offering insights into their value propositions for different buyers. The Tisas PX 57 is highlighted as the budget-friendly option, the S&W M&P 57 as feature-rich, and the Ruger 57 as a well-established choice.

Quick Summary

Comparing the Tisas PX 57, Smith & Wesson M&P 57, and Ruger 57 5.7x28mm pistols, the Tisas PX 57 is the budget leader at $400, made in Turkey. The S&W M&P 57 ($600) is feature-rich with a threaded barrel and optics cut. The Ruger 57 ($800) is American-made but has a less desirable trigger. Ergonomics favor the Tisas PX 57 for its comfortable grip.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: 5.7mm Pistol Options
  2. 00:34Tisas PX 57: Specs and Features
  3. 02:07Smith & Wesson M&P 57: Specs and Features
  4. 03:42Ruger 57: Specs and Features
  5. 04:46Trigger Comparison
  6. 05:37Price Comparison: Tisas vs S&W vs Ruger
  7. 06:51Weight and Ergonomic Comparison
  8. 08:17Personal Opinions and Recommendations
  9. 09:04Viewer Choice and Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between the Tisas PX 57, Smith & Wesson M&P 57, and Ruger 57?

The Tisas PX 57 is the most budget-friendly at around $400, made in Turkey, with basic features. The S&W M&P 57 costs about $600, is American-made, optics-ready, and has a threaded barrel. The Ruger 57, around $800, is also American-made but has the least appealing trigger and is the oldest design.

Which 5.7x28mm pistol offers the best value for money?

The Tisas PX 57 offers the best value if budget is the primary concern, priced around $400. While it lacks features like an optics cut, it provides a 5.7x28mm platform at an accessible price point. The S&W M&P 57 offers more features for its price, making it a strong contender for value if budget allows.

How do the triggers compare on the Tisas PX 57, S&W M&P 57, and Ruger 57?

The Smith & Wesson M&P 57's trigger is considered the best, being slightly lighter and good overall. The Tisas PX 57 has a decent but slightly heavy trigger. The Ruger 57's trigger is the least appealing, with noticeable creep, sponginess, and a distant reset.

What are the ergonomic differences between these 5.7mm pistols?

The Tisas PX 57 is praised for its comfortable, round grip feel. The Smith & Wesson M&P 57 is noted for being very skinny and squared off. The Ruger 57's grip is also described as more squared off, potentially favoring those with larger hands for the PX 57.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Gun Deity

View all →