Brownells Retro XM177E2

Published on November 11, 2019
Duration: 21:46

The Brownells Retro XM177E2 offers a visually accurate clone of the iconic Vietnam-era carbine but suffers from significant build quality issues. While fun to shoot, the plastic stock is described as 'junk,' and the finish is criticized for its 'purplish' hue compared to original Colt grey parkerizing. Sight adjustment problems and the necessary NFA pin-and-weld modification detract from its authenticity and value.

Quick Summary

The Brownells Retro XM177E2 replica faces criticism for its 'junk' plastic stock and purplish finish, contrasting with original Colt rifles. While visually appealing and historically relevant, build quality issues and necessary NFA pin-and-weld modifications detract from its authenticity.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Initial Shooting
  2. 01:12Historical Context: Vietnam Era Carbine
  3. 02:41Muzzle Device Function & Reliability Issues
  4. 04:26Magazines & Sponsor Break (APMEX)
  5. 07:01Sight Adjustment Problems
  6. 08:01Comparison: Brownells vs. Colt SP1
  7. 09:49Criticism: Plastic Stock Quality
  8. 11:31NFA Compliance: Pin & Weld
  9. 12:30Final Verdict & Recommendations

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main criticisms of the Brownells Retro XM177E2 replica?

The primary criticisms focus on build quality, specifically the plastic collapsible stock which is described as 'junk' and difficult to adjust. The finish is also noted as having a 'purplish' hue, unlike the correct grey parkerizing of original Colt rifles. Sight adjustment issues were also reported.

How does the Brownells XM177E2 compare to original Colt models?

While visually similar, the Brownells replica falls short in build quality. The plastic stock is a significant downgrade from Colt's aluminum stocks. The finish also differs, with Brownells having a purplish tint compared to Colt's grey parkerizing. Receiver fencing and forward assist styles also show differences.

Is the Brownells XM177E2 NFA compliant?

Yes, the Brownells XM177E2 is made NFA compliant for civilian sale. Its barrel is under 16 inches, so the muzzle device is pinned and welded to meet the legal minimum barrel length requirement, though the weld mark is visible.

What is the historical significance of the XM177E2?

The XM177E2 is an iconic Vietnam-era carbine, favored by Special Forces (SOG) and Navy SEALs for its compact size, ideal for jungle warfare and reconnaissance. It served as a direct predecessor to the modern M4 carbine.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from hickok45

View all →