Brownells Retro XM177E2

Published on November 11, 2019
Duration: 21:46

John Hickok provides a critical review of the Brownells Retro XM177E2, praising its historical accuracy and fun factor but highlighting significant shortcomings in build quality, particularly the finish and plastic stock. He details its Vietnam-era origins, NFA compliance modifications, and compares it unfavorably to original Colt models, ultimately suggesting enthusiasts might consider building their own clones from retro parts.

Quick Summary

The Brownells Retro XM177E2, a replica of the Vietnam-era carbine, faces criticism for its 'purplish' finish and low-quality plastic stock, contrasting with original Colt models. It achieves NFA compliance for its short barrel via a pinned and welded muzzle device, making it a fun but flawed historical reproduction.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Initial Shooting
  2. 01:12Historical Context
  3. 02:41Muzzle Device and Reliability
  4. 04:26Magazines and Sponsor Break
  5. 07:01Sight Adjustment Issues
  6. 08:01Comparison with Colt SP1
  7. 09:49Stock and Build Quality
  8. 11:31NFA Compliance and Muzzle Welding
  9. 12:30Final Recommendations

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main criticisms of the Brownells Retro XM177E2?

The primary criticisms focus on build quality: the finish has a noticeable 'purplish' hue instead of the correct grey parkerizing, and the plastic collapsible stock is described as 'junk,' difficult to adjust, and prone to grinding.

How does the Brownells Retro XM177E2 achieve NFA compliance?

The rifle features a barrel shorter than the 16-inch legal minimum for rifles. To comply with NFA regulations, the muzzle device is permanently attached via a pin and weld process, bringing the total barrel length to the legal 16.1 inches.

What historical significance does the XM177E2 hold?

The XM177E2 was an iconic carbine used by US Special Forces (SOG) and Navy SEALs during the Vietnam War. It represented a move towards shorter, more compact rifles for specialized roles and served as a direct predecessor to the modern M4 carbine.

How does the Brownells XM177E2 compare to an original Colt SP1?

When compared to a 1983 Colt SP1, the Brownells replica falls short in finish quality and stock construction. The Colt exhibits a proper grey parkerized finish and a solid aluminum stock, whereas the Brownells model has a purplish finish and a flimsy plastic stock.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from hickok45

View all →