Cimarron Schofield 5-Inch 45 Colt

Published on September 26, 2023
Duration: 20:11

The Cimarron Schofield 5-inch revolver in .45 Colt offers a historical replica experience with a unique top-break action. While visually appealing and historically significant, its tight tolerances can make it sensitive to ammunition variations, and the extraction process requires careful technique to avoid jams. Compared to a Colt Single Action Army, its ergonomics are noted as slightly less comfortable, and its top-break design is inherently less robust for modern high-pressure loads.

Quick Summary

The Cimarron Schofield 5-inch revolver in .45 Colt features a historical top-break action, often associated with Wells Fargo. Be aware of tight tolerances that can bind with certain .45 Colt ammunition and the need to hold the gun upright during extraction to prevent jams.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Range Test
  2. 00:415-Inch vs 7-Inch Barrel Comparison
  3. 01:21Historical Significance: US Military & Wells Fargo
  4. 03:21Design & Ergonomics: Top-Break vs SAA
  5. 05:13Ammunition Sensitivity & Tight Tolerances
  6. 07:15.45 Schofield vs .45 Colt Cartridge Differences
  7. 10:27Extraction Demonstration & Jam Warning
  8. 11:38Final Thoughts, Pricing & Design Limitations

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the historical significance of the 5-inch Cimarron Schofield revolver?

The 5-inch barrel Cimarron Schofield is often referred to as the 'Wells Fargo' model. Historically, Wells Fargo purchased surplus Schofield revolvers from the US military and shortened the barrels to 5 inches for their agents, making this variant a nod to that specific historical use.

What are the main differences between the Schofield and a Colt Single Action Army?

The primary difference is the action: the Schofield features a top-break design for quick ejection, while the Colt SAA has a solid frame. Hickok45 notes that while the Schofield is fascinating, its ergonomics feel slightly more awkward than a Colt SAA.

What potential issues should users be aware of with the Cimarron Schofield?

This Cimarron model has very tight tolerances, making it sensitive to ammunition. Some .45 Colt cartridges with slightly longer overall lengths or wider bullets can cause the cylinder to bind. Additionally, spent casings can jam if the gun isn't held upright during extraction.

What is the approximate price and historical context of the Schofield revolver's decline?

The Cimarron Schofield 5-inch has an MSRP around $800. The top-break design eventually lost favor because solid-frame revolvers are inherently stronger and better suited for handling modern, higher-pressure ammunition loads.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from hickok45

View all →