HK Fails With SP-5? A Discussion -- KC&C Ep. 59 w/ Steve_MP5

Published on December 6, 2019
Duration: 79:29

This discussion between a firearms instructor and an MP5 enthusiast delves into the Heckler & Koch SP5's release and market reception. Key points include its high price point compared to clones like POF, Zenith, and PTR, the omission of traditional diopter sights, and the debate over its pinned lower receiver. The conversation also touches on the appeal of the MP5 platform, its historical significance, and comparisons to other PCCs like the UMP and AR-9s.

Quick Summary

The Heckler & Koch SP5 faces criticism for its high price point, lack of traditional diopter sights, and a non-pinned lower receiver, making clones from POF, Zenith, and PTR more attractive value propositions for many buyers. Despite these drawbacks, its authentic HK branding and iconic MP5 design maintain its appeal.

Chapters

  1. 00:02Introduction & Channel Updates
  2. 06:08Introducing Guest Steve & MP5 Expertise
  3. 07:15Steve's Background & MP5 Passion
  4. 08:14Die Hard's Influence on MP5 Craze
  5. 09:56Understanding Reverse Stretch MP5 Clones
  6. 11:04Initial Impressions of the HK SP5
  7. 12:00Demo Guns & Influencer Distribution
  8. 13:02Not an HK Hater: Instructor's Perspective
  9. 13:47SP5 Release & Range TV Review
  10. 14:43SP5 Initial Pros and Cons
  11. 15:12SP5 Features: Paddle Mag Release
  12. 15:50SP5 Price Point vs. Competition
  13. 16:14TFBT TV Review & Value Assessment
  14. 16:51MP5 Clone Market: Dakota, TPM, Omega
  15. 17:08PTR, POF, Zenith as Alternatives
  16. 17:53SP5 MSRP & Caliber Discussion
  17. 18:48HK Fan's Perspective on SP5 vs. Clones
  18. 20:04Frustrations with SP5 Differences
  19. 20:16TFB TV: HK Factory Built MP5
  20. 21:05SP5 vs. SBR'd Clones
  21. 21:12SP5 Diopter Sights vs. MP5K Sights
  22. 23:13Demonstrating Diopter Sights
  23. 24:25HK's 'Stop Being Poor' Mentality?
  24. 24:45SP5 Driving Sales to UMP45?
  25. 26:33Building a UMP: Parts Kits & Receivers
  26. 28:04SP5 vs. HK 94 Comparison
  27. 29:23The Pinned Lower Receiver Issue
  28. 30:21Roller Delayed vs. Direct Blowback
  29. 31:30German Export Laws & UN Arms Treaty
  30. 34:20MP5 vs. UMP: Which is the Go-To?
  31. 36:37Tactical Pineapple on UN Arms Treaty
  32. 37:00POF vs. Other Brands: If Money Was No Object
  33. 39:12Winning a Shotgun in the UK Scenario
  34. 40:49Kriss Vector vs. HK MP5 Preference
  35. 43:14Is the HK SP5 Worth the Price?
  36. 44:08Comment Section Debate: SP5 vs. Zenith
  37. 45:45New Shooters & MP5 Search Results
  38. 47:02Recommended MP5 Clones: POF, Zenith, PTR
  39. 49:26POF vs. Zenith Finish & Packaging
  40. 52:14FMP G3 vs. HK91 & MP5 Clones
  41. 52:35PCC vs. 5.56: FMJ vs. JHP Ammo
  42. 53:28CMMG Banshee vs. MP5 for PCCs
  43. 54:03AR-9s vs. MP5: Pros and Cons
  44. 56:38AR-9 Pricing and Reliability Concerns
  45. 59:12HK Arrogance & Collector Pricing
  46. 61:02Home Defense Ammo: JHP vs. FMJ
  47. 63:35Bill to Repeal NFA & SBRs
  48. 64:15Favorite Home Defense Guns
  49. 66:20New Surefire Scout Light
  50. 66:52SIG MPX vs. Other PCCs
  51. 68:09UMP as MP5 Successor
  52. 69:04Apocalypse Loadout: Armament & Vehicle
  53. 72:21Home Defense in an Apartment: PCC vs. 5.56
  54. 75:08SP5 Fails: Overpriced, Sights, Lower
  55. 76:52Favorite Weapon: The MP5
  56. 77:13Outro & Guest Information

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main criticisms of the Heckler & Koch SP5?

The primary criticisms of the HK SP5 include its high price point compared to MP5 clones, the omission of traditional diopter sights in favor of MP5K-sized sights, and the non-pinned trigger group, which is attributed to import restrictions but is a point of contention among enthusiasts.

How does the HK SP5 compare to its clones like POF, Zenith, and PTR?

While the SP5 is an authentic HK product, clones like POF, Zenith, and PTR offer similar functionality and aesthetics at a significantly lower price. Clones often come with more accessories and may feature traditional pinned lowers, which the SP5 lacks due to import regulations.

Why is the MP5 platform still popular?

The MP5's enduring popularity stems from its iconic status, largely popularized by media like the Die Hard films. Its roller-delayed blowback system provides a smooth shooting experience, and it remains a highly recognizable and desirable firearm for collectors and enthusiasts.

What are the key differences between the HK SP5 and older HK 94 models?

The HK SP5 features a paddle magazine release, which was not present on the older HK 94 models. Both are subject to import restrictions that affect their lower receiver design, with the SP5 lacking the traditional two-pin setup found on many clones.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Fit'n Fire

View all →