New Marlin vs Old Marlin

Published on December 18, 2018
Duration: 27:33

This review compares a new Marlin Model 1894 Cowboy to an older 'JM' marked model, highlighting differences in fit, finish, and manufacturing quality. While the new rifle is accurate and functional, its wood-to-metal fit, matte finish, and minor quality control issues like rusted screws are noted as drawbacks compared to the glossier, better-finished older JM models. The new Marlin is priced around $850, with older JM models still available on the used market.

Quick Summary

The new Marlin 1894 Cowboy features a 20-inch matte barrel and costs around $850, but exhibits poorer wood-to-metal fit and minor QC issues like rusted screws compared to older JM models. Despite this, it shoots accurately.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: New vs Old Marlin 1894
  2. 00:47Model Specs: Barrel Length & Checkering
  3. 01:45Sights: Skinner vs Factory Buckhorn
  4. 03:28Range Testing: .357 Magnum & .38 Special
  5. 05:23Action & Cycling: Break-in Period
  6. 06:24Fit and Finish Critique: Matte vs Gloss
  7. 10:00Pricing and Market Value Comparison
  8. 11:00Loading Mechanics: .357 Magnum Challenges
  9. 13:12Quality Control Issues: Rusted Screws
  10. 14:40Conclusion: New Marlin vs JM Era

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between the new Marlin 1894 Cowboy and older JM Marlins?

The new Marlin 1894 Cowboy has a 20-inch matte finish barrel, while older JM models typically feature a 24-inch gloss finish. Key differences also lie in wood-to-metal fit, with the new model showing gaps, and the presence of modern markings like QR codes on the new rifle.

How does the fit and finish of the new Marlin 1894 compare to older JM models?

The new Marlin 1894's fit and finish are generally considered inferior to older JM models. Specific criticisms include gaps around the forend and tang, a less refined wood-to-metal fit, and minor cosmetic flaws like rusted screws on a brand-new rifle.

Is the new Marlin 1894 accurate for its price point?

Yes, the new Marlin 1894 Model 1894 Cowboy demonstrates good accuracy, effectively hitting steel targets at various distances with both .357 Magnum and .38 Special ammunition, despite its fit and finish concerns.

What quality control issues were noted on the new Marlin 1894?

The review highlighted visible rust on the buttplate screws of the brand-new Marlin 1894, suggesting potential lapses in quality control or the finishing process. The wood-to-metal fit was also criticized as being less precise than older JM models.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from hickok45

View all →