Roller-Delay Showdown: Angstadt MDP-9 vs H&K SP-5

Published on August 20, 2022
Duration: 14:24

This video features Ian McCollum, a recognized firearms historian, conducting a performance comparison between the Angstadt Arms MDP-9 and the Heckler & Koch SP-5. Both are 9mm roller-delayed blowback firearms tested in a timed course of fire. The MDP-9 demonstrated slightly faster times but experienced reliability issues, while the SP-5 was more consistent. The video also covers suppressed shooting and ergonomic differences.

Quick Summary

Firearms historian Ian McCollum compares the Angstadt Arms MDP-9 and H&K SP-5, both roller-delayed blowback 9mm firearms. The MDP-9 is lighter and faster in timed drills but has reliability issues, while the SP-5 is more consistent. Suppressed shooting on the MDP-9 showed minimal gas blowback.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Comparison Setup
  2. 01:37Angstadt MDP-9 Initial Performance
  3. 02:32H&K SP-5 Initial Performance
  4. 03:44Reliability Issues and Subsequent Runs
  5. 09:15Suppressed Shooting and Gas Blowback
  6. 12:41Final Assessment and Ergonomics

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the Angstadt Arms MDP-9 and the H&K SP-5?

The MDP-9 is lighter, narrower, and uses Glock magazines with AR-15 style controls, while the SP-5 is heavier, wider, uses proprietary H&K magazines, and has a more traditional roller-delayed feel. Both are roller-delayed blowback 9mm firearms with similar MSRPs.

How did the Angstadt MDP-9 and H&K SP-5 perform in timed drills?

In timed drills, the MDP-9 was slightly faster on average, but experienced a double-feed malfunction. The SP-5 was more consistent and reliable, though marginally slower overall in this specific test scenario.

Is the Angstadt MDP-9 suitable for suppressed shooting?

Yes, the MDP-9 performed well when suppressed with a Dead Air Wolfman and subsonic ammunition, exhibiting minimal gas blowback from the ejection port, which is a significant advantage for shooters.

What are the main criticisms of the Angstadt Arms MDP-9?

Criticisms of the MDP-9 include its heavy trigger, the unreliability of its last-round bolt hold open feature, and the lack of an ambidextrous safety at its price point, despite its competitive speed potential.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →