Rugers Are NOT Stronger than Smith & Wessons!..You're Wrong!..Get Over It!

Published on February 27, 2024
Duration: 8:01

This video debunks the myth that Ruger revolvers are inherently stronger than Smith & Wesson revolvers. The instructor explains that perceived strength differences are often due to manufacturing methods (cast vs. forged) and, more importantly, frame and cylinder size variations. He emphasizes that comparing revolvers of different frame sizes is misleading and that when comparing similar frame sizes, both brands offer comparable strength.

Quick Summary

Ruger revolvers are not inherently stronger than Smith & Wesson revolvers. Perceived differences are mainly due to Ruger's cast manufacturing, making them appear thicker, and crucially, their frame and cylinder size. When comparing revolvers of similar frame sizes, their strength capabilities are comparable.

Chapters

  1. 00:06Introduction: Ruger vs. S&W Strength Myth
  2. 00:19Why People Think Rugers Are Stronger
  3. 00:34Cast vs. Forged Manufacturing
  4. 01:15Comparing Medium Frame Revolvers (GP100 vs. 686)
  5. 01:53Understanding Frame Sizes: Vaquero vs. Blackhawk
  6. 02:09Ruger Only Loads Explained
  7. 03:06The Importance of Comparing Similar Frame Sizes
  8. 03:21Comparing Large Frame Revolvers (Blackhawk vs. N-Frame S&W)
  9. 03:38Comparing .45 Colt and .44 Magnum Loads
  10. 04:28Extra Large Frame Comparison (Super Blackhawk vs. X-Frame)
  11. 05:04Ruger Alaskan vs. S&W 460
  12. 05:27Conclusion: Size Dictates Strength
  13. 05:55Quality and Personal Preference

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Ruger revolvers inherently stronger than Smith & Wesson revolvers?

No, Ruger revolvers are not inherently stronger. Perceived strength differences are often due to Ruger's cast manufacturing, making them appear thicker, and more significantly, the frame and cylinder size. When comparing revolvers of similar frame sizes, their strength is comparable.

Why do 'Ruger only' loads exist?

'Ruger only' loads exist because certain Ruger revolvers, like the Blackhawk, have larger frames and longer cylinders designed to safely handle higher pressure or longer cartridges. These loads are not suitable for smaller-framed revolvers, regardless of manufacturer.

What is the main factor determining a revolver's strength?

The primary factor determining a revolver's strength is its frame size. Larger frames can accommodate thicker components, longer cylinders, and higher pressure ammunition, making them inherently capable of handling more powerful loads than smaller-framed revolvers.

How does cast vs. forged manufacturing affect revolver strength?

Cast manufacturing, often used by Ruger, can result in thicker components that appear stronger. Forged manufacturing, used by Smith & Wesson, allows for thinner components that are equally strong, meaning thickness alone doesn't equate to superior inherent strength.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →