Smith and Wesson M&P 40 versus SD40VE versus Glock 23- side by side by side comparison

Published on July 10, 2024
Duration: 15:38

This review compares the Smith & Wesson M&P 40, SD40VE, and Glock 23 in .40 S&W. The M&P 40 is highlighted for its superior ergonomics, heavier slide contributing to less felt recoil, and best overall shooting experience, making it a recommended value, especially as a police trade-in. The SD40VE is noted for its lighter weight and sharper recoil, while the Glock 23, despite its reliability reputation, experienced extraction issues during testing with the specific ammunition used.

Quick Summary

The Smith & Wesson M&P 40 is recommended as the best value and performer among the M&P 40, SD40VE, and Glock 23 in .40 S&W. It offers superior ergonomics, a heavier slide for reduced recoil, and a comfortable shooting experience, especially as a police trade-in. The SD40VE is lighter with sharper recoil, while the Glock 23 experienced extraction issues during testing.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Setup
  2. 00:48Comparing Three .40 S&W Handguns
  3. 00:51Smith & Wesson M&P 40 Overview
  4. 01:08Smith & Wesson SD40VE Overview
  5. 01:34Glock 23 Overview
  6. 02:00Initial Handling Impressions
  7. 02:34Shooting Test Begins
  8. 02:56M&P 40 Shooting Experience
  9. 04:39SD40VE Shooting Experience
  10. 05:40Glock 23 Shooting Experience & Issues
  11. 07:00Controllability Comparison Update
  12. 07:32Accuracy Shooting Setup
  13. 08:07Target Setup and Distance
  14. 08:15M&P 40 Accuracy Test
  15. 09:25SD40VE Accuracy Test
  16. 10:12Glock 23 Accuracy Test
  17. 10:53Accuracy and Effectiveness Conclusion
  18. 11:47Overall Comparison and Conclusion
  19. 11:49M&P 40: Best Overall Value and Performance
  20. 13:35SD40VE: Mid-Range Performance and Cost
  21. 14:36Glock 23: Most Expensive, Reliability Concerns
  22. 15:22Final Thoughts and Sign-off

Frequently Asked Questions

Which .40 S&W handgun is best for recoil control among the M&P 40, SD40VE, and Glock 23?

The Smith & Wesson M&P 40 is generally considered the most controllable due to its heavier weight and slide, which helps mitigate felt recoil compared to the lighter SD40VE. The Glock 23's recoil is manageable, but its grip angle can affect shooting for some.

What are the key differences in ergonomics between the S&W M&P 40, SD40VE, and Glock 23?

The M&P 40 offers a full-size grip with adjustable backstraps for a customizable fit. The SD40VE has a slightly shorter and less thick grip with less effective stippling. The Glock 23's grip angle is distinct and can lead to shooting low for some users.

How does the accuracy compare between the Smith & Wesson M&P 40, SD40VE, and Glock 23?

At approximately 5 yards, the accuracy between the M&P 40, SD40VE, and Glock 23 was found to be comparable. All three firearms demonstrated effective performance on target during the testing conducted in the video.

What are the price and value considerations for the M&P 40, SD40VE, and Glock 23?

The M&P 40 police trade-ins offer excellent value, often found for $225-$275. The SD40VE is mid-range ($350-$450) with cheaper magazines. The Glock 23 is typically the most expensive used ($600+), but its magazines are also affordable.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Cranky Gun Reviews

View all →