Staccato "XC"$5,500 vs "P" 2011 $3,500? 9mm 20 rounds Weapons Education- STI

Published on November 19, 2023
Duration: 21:49

This video provides an in-depth comparison of the Staccato XC and Staccato P 9mm pistols, highlighting their price points, build quality, and performance differences. The presenter, Tom from Weapons Education, emphasizes the XC's semi-custom nature, single gunsmith build, and lighter recoil spring (8 lbs) contributing to its exceptional performance and 2.5 lb trigger pull. The P model, while still high-quality, features a heavier 11 lb spring and a trigger pull of 4-4.5 lbs. The video discusses the premium features of the XC, including its compensator and lightning cuts, and touches on the potential for future 10mm or .45 ACP variants.

Quick Summary

The Staccato XC is a semi-custom 9mm 2011 pistol built by a single gunsmith, featuring an 8 lb recoil spring and a 2.5 lb trigger for exceptionally low recoil and fast follow-up shots. It costs over $5,000. The Staccato P, while also high-quality, uses an 11 lb spring and a 4-4.5 lb trigger, priced around $3,500-$4,000.

Chapters

  1. 00:01Introduction to Staccato Comparison
  2. 00:48Introducing the Staccato XC
  3. 01:09Introducing the Staccato P Model
  4. 01:45XC Price Point and Value
  5. 02:00P Model Price Point and Value
  6. 02:31Shooting Impressions of the XC
  7. 03:01Justifying the Cost of Staccato
  8. 03:44Fit and Feel of Staccato Pistols
  9. 04:06Negative: 9mm Only
  10. 05:069mm for Self-Defense and Competition
  11. 05:36Polymer Frame Ergonomics
  12. 05:52In-House Parts Manufacturing
  13. 06:04Focus on the XC Model
  14. 06:13XC Competition Model Details
  15. 07:07XC Trigger Pull Weight
  16. 07:32XC's Semi-Custom Build
  17. 07:51XC Recoil Reduction
  18. 08:09XC Compensator
  19. 08:45XC Recoil Spring Weight
  20. 09:10P Model Recoil Spring Weight
  21. 09:31XC vs. P: Key Differences
  22. 10:25XC Trigger Revisited
  23. 10:35XC Accessories: Red Dot and Light
  24. 11:04XC Slide Lightning Cuts
  25. 11:20XC Barrel Quality
  26. 12:03XC Slide Action
  27. 12:432011 Reliability
  28. 13:24XC Magwell Design
  29. 13:55XC Grip Texture
  30. 14:24XC Ambidextrous Safety
  31. 14:57Introducing the P Model
  32. 15:00P Model Accessories
  33. 15:18P Model Red Dot and Sights
  34. 16:07Presenter's Red Dot Preference
  35. 16:17P Model Unfired Status
  36. 16:27P Model Trigger Pull
  37. 16:52Flat Trigger Preference
  38. 17:00Request for 10mm/45 ACP
  39. 17:07Ammunition Recommendations
  40. 17:34P Model Slide Action
  41. 18:08Company Manufacturing Philosophy
  42. 18:34John Wick Movie Impact
  43. 19:07P Model Threaded Barrel
  44. 19:46Slide Top Flattening
  45. 20:01Precision Made Parts
  46. 20:10Trigger Guard Design
  47. 20:15Magwell Comparison
  48. 20:22Back Grip Safety
  49. 20:39Modern 1911 Design
  50. 20:46Future Plans and Testing
  51. 21:11Sig Academy Torture Test
  52. 21:19Conclusion and Call to Action

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main difference between the Staccato XC and Staccato P pistols?

The primary differences lie in their build process and performance features. The XC is a semi-custom pistol built by a single gunsmith with an 8 lb recoil spring and a 2.5 lb trigger, offering significantly reduced recoil. The P model uses an 11 lb spring and has a 4-4.5 lb trigger, making it a high-quality production firearm but less specialized than the XC.

How much do the Staccato XC and Staccato P pistols typically cost?

The Staccato XC is the more expensive model, costing over $5,000, with fully accessorized versions reaching around $5,500. The Staccato P is more affordable, with prices ranging from approximately $3,500 to $4,000 when equipped with accessories like red dots and lights.

What makes the Staccato XC's recoil so low?

The Staccato XC achieves its exceptionally low recoil through a combination of factors, most notably its fixed compensator and a significantly lighter 8 lb recoil spring. This setup reduces felt recoil by about 30% compared to a standard 9mm, allowing for faster follow-up shots.

Does Staccato manufacture all their pistol parts in-house?

Yes, Staccato emphasizes that they manufacture all of their pistol parts in-house. This vertical integration is highlighted as a key factor in their ability to maintain high quality control and precision in their firearms, from the XC to the P model.

What is the trigger pull weight for the Staccato XC and P models?

The Staccato XC features a remarkably light and crisp trigger pull of 2.5 lbs, often described as 'feather-light.' In contrast, the Staccato P has a trigger pull weight in the range of 4 to 4.5 lbs, which is still good but noticeably heavier than the XC's.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Weapons Education

View all →