Videos tagged with Remand

This video outlines three potential outcomes for the Duncan v. Bonta case at the Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS). The possibilities include accepting the case for oral arguments and an opinion, declining to hear it, or issuing a GVR (Grant, Vacate, and Remand). The discussion touches on the ramifications of each decision and how SCOTUS might handle cases based on other Second Amendment rulings.

This video, presented by William Kirk of Washington Gun Law, analyzes the 'Reese v. ATF' case. It details how a significant Fifth Circuit ruling declaring federal handgun sales bans unconstitutional for 18-20 year olds was undermined by the Department of Justice's proposed judgment. The DOJ's narrow interpretation of the ruling, limiting relief to a specific group and requiring membership lists, has drawn strong criticism from plaintiffs like the Second Amendment Foundation and Firearms Policy Coalition.

This video provides an expert legal analysis of the Fifth Circuit's ruling in Vanderstock v. Garland, which overturned the ATF's rule on unfinished frames and receivers (80% lowers). The ruling found the ATF exceeded its statutory authority by redefining 'frame or receiver' beyond Congressional intent. The court emphasized strict interpretation of laws, especially when criminal liability is involved, and remanded the remedy to the District Court. This is presented as a significant victory for lawful gun owners.

The case Duncan v. Bonta challenges California's ban on high-capacity magazines. Initially, a district court granted an injunction, but the Ninth Circuit reinstated the ban. The Supreme Court granted review, vacated the Ninth Circuit's ruling, and remanded the case for reconsideration based on the Bruin standard. The Ninth Circuit has now sent the case back to the district court, likely as a delay tactic, where Judge Benitez is expected to rule against the ban again.