Will Gun Control be snuck into Infrastructure?... NOT LIKELY and here's WHY...

Published on September 25, 2021
Duration: 5:18

This video explains why gun control measures are unlikely to be 'snuck' into an infrastructure package via reconciliation. The speaker details the 'Bird Rule,' which prohibits extraneous matters not tied to the budget in reconciliation bills. A recent ruling on immigration reform serves as a case study, demonstrating how the Senate Parliamentarian can block such attempts. The process requires a 60-vote majority to overcome a point of order against extraneous provisions, a threshold currently unattainable for such measures.

Quick Summary

Gun control measures are unlikely to be 'snuck' into infrastructure packages via reconciliation due to the 'Bird Rule.' This rule prohibits extraneous policy matters not directly tied to the budget. A recent ruling blocking immigration reform highlights how the Senate Parliamentarian can enforce this, requiring a 60-vote majority to overcome challenges to non-budgetary provisions.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Gun Control & Infrastructure
  2. 00:11The Core Question: Sliding Gun Control
  3. 01:18Reconciliation Explained: 50 vs 60 Votes
  4. 01:34The Bird Rule: What It Prohibits
  5. 01:51Immigration Reform Case Study
  6. 02:49Parliamentarian's Ruling on Immigration
  7. 03:37Parliamentarian's Memo Details
  8. 04:08Why Gun Control Fails the 'Incidental' Test
  9. 04:22Enforcing the Bird Rule: Point of Order
  10. 04:33Government Designed to Work Slowly
  11. 04:41Executive Actions vs. Legislation
  12. 04:53Conclusion: What's Likely to Pass

Frequently Asked Questions

Can gun control be included in an infrastructure package through reconciliation?

It is highly unlikely. Reconciliation bills must adhere to the 'Bird Rule,' which prohibits extraneous matters not directly tied to the budget. Gun control is considered a policy issue, not a budget item, and would require a 60-vote majority to overcome a point of order if included.

What is the 'Bird Rule' in the U.S. Senate?

The Bird Rule, under Senate rules, prevents reconciliation bills from containing provisions where the budget effect is merely incidental to the overall policy impact. This ensures that reconciliation is used for budget matters, not unrelated policy changes.

How does the Senate Parliamentarian influence legislation like infrastructure bills?

The Senate Parliamentarian acts as the rule enforcer. They review proposed legislation, like reconciliation bills, to determine if provisions comply with Senate rules, such as the Bird Rule. Their rulings can block specific measures from being included.

Why was immigration reform blocked from the infrastructure package?

Immigration reform was blocked because the Senate Parliamentarian ruled that its provisions had policy impacts that were merely incidental to any budget effect, thus violating the Bird Rule. This ruling set a precedent for similar policy-heavy measures.

Related News

All News →

More 2nd Amendment & Law Videos You Might Like

More from Langley Outdoors Academy

View all →