Revolver vs Semi-auto for pocket carry

Published on January 16, 2021
Duration: 18:17

This video compares revolvers and semi-automatic pistols for pocket carry, focusing on practical considerations for everyday concealed carry. The instructor, with apparent experience in firearms instruction, details differences in capacity, reloading methods (speed loaders vs. speed strips vs. magazines), pocket profile, weight, and trigger characteristics. Key takeaways include that semi-autos generally offer higher capacity, while revolvers can be simpler to operate under stress. The discussion also touches on caliber effectiveness and the nuances of pocket carry concealment.

Quick Summary

When comparing revolvers and semi-automatic pistols for pocket carry, semi-autos typically offer higher ammunition capacity and faster magazine reloads. Revolvers can be simpler to operate, but their reloads are slower. Both have distinct pocket profiles and weight considerations that affect concealment and comfort. Semi-automatic safety concerns include the 'out of battery' condition, while revolvers are generally simpler and more reliable in pocket carry.

Chapters

  1. 00:13Pocket Carry: Revolver vs. Semi-Auto
  2. 00:56Capacity Differences
  3. 01:17Reloading Methods: Semi-Auto vs. Revolver
  4. 01:36How Speed Strips Work
  5. 03:14Speed Loader Demonstration
  6. 03:43Pocket Profile: Speed Loader vs. Speed Strip
  7. 04:24Semi-Auto Reloading
  8. 05:03Reloading Demonstration: Semi-Auto
  9. 05:03Reloading Demonstration: Speed Strip
  10. 05:47Reloading Demonstration: Speed Loader
  11. 06:21Pocket Carry in Winter & Safety
  12. 06:46Semi-Auto Safety: Out of Battery
  13. 07:51Revolver Pocket Carry Safety
  14. 08:03Caliber Comparison: .380 ACP vs. .38 Special
  15. 09:11Physical Dimensions & Concealment
  16. 10:39Width Comparison: Cylinder vs. Slide
  17. 11:37Weight Comparison
  18. 12:45Trigger Comparison
  19. 15:16Trigger Pull Weight Measurement
  20. 17:40Conclusion & Social Media

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between revolvers and semi-autos for pocket carry?

Semi-automatics generally offer higher ammunition capacity and faster magazine reloads. Revolvers can be simpler to operate, but their reloads with speed strips or speed loaders are typically slower. Both have distinct pocket profiles and weight considerations that affect concealment and comfort.

How does caliber affect pocket carry effectiveness?

While both .380 ACP and .38 Special are considered lower-tier defensive calibers, .38 Special generally has a slight power advantage due to its ability to use heavier bullet weights. Both can be effective with proper bullet selection.

What are the safety considerations for pocket carrying a semi-automatic pistol?

A key safety concern with semi-automatics is the 'out of battery' condition. If the slide is pushed back, even slightly, by pressing against an object in a pocket, the firearm will not fire. Revolvers do not have this vulnerability.

How do the triggers of pocket revolvers and semi-autos compare?

Semi-automatic triggers, like those on many compact pistols, typically have shorter take-up, a crisper break, and a shorter reset. Double-action revolver triggers have a longer, heavier pull that rotates the cylinder, and require a full trigger release for reset, making them generally less shootable for some.

Related News

All News →

More EDC & Lifestyle Videos You Might Like

More from The Gun Dungeon

View all →