S&W Shield's Deadly Flaw

Published on August 15, 2013
Duration: 4:56

This entry details a critical flaw identified in the Smith & Wesson M&P Shield's manual thumb safety, which can inadvertently engage during carry. The speaker, with high authority based on personal carry experience and mechanical demonstrations, highlights the potential danger this poses for concealed carry. While praising the Shield's grip ergonomics compared to competitors like the Springfield XDS and Sig Sauer P290, the core issue remains the unreliable safety mechanism.

Quick Summary

The S&W M&P Shield's manual thumb safety is criticized for engaging too easily and unintentionally during carry, potentially hindering immediate use in self-defense. While praised for grip comfort over competitors like the Springfield XDS and Sig P290, this safety flaw is deemed a significant risk for concealed carry.

Chapters

  1. 00:20Introduction to S&W Shield
  2. 01:29The 'Deadly Flaw': Safety Engagement
  3. 02:42Self-Defense Implications
  4. 03:35Comparisons and Grip Ergonomics

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main criticism of the Smith & Wesson M&P Shield discussed in the video?

The primary criticism is the manual thumb safety, which can inadvertently engage itself due to friction during carry. This is considered a potentially deadly flaw for a concealed carry weapon, as it might prevent immediate deployment in a defensive situation.

How does the S&W M&P Shield's safety mechanism behave?

The manual safety on the S&W M&P Shield is reported to engage too easily, often clicking 'on' by itself when rubbing against a holster or bag. Furthermore, it may require more pressure to disengage than to engage.

How does the S&W M&P Shield compare ergonomically to other subcompact pistols?

Despite the safety issue, the speaker finds the S&W M&P Shield to have superior grip comfort when compared to the Springfield Armory XDS and the Sig Sauer P290. This ergonomic advantage is noted as a positive aspect of the firearm.

What are the self-defense implications of the S&W Shield's safety flaw?

An unreliable safety that can engage on its own poses a significant risk in a self-defense scenario. If a user expects the firearm to be ready for immediate use but the safety has inadvertently engaged, it could lead to a critical failure to act.

Related News

All News →

More EDC & Lifestyle Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →