Why five‑shot .38 Specials are obsolete for carry

Published on February 13, 2026
Duration: 1:57

The Yankee Marshal argues that five-shot .38 Special revolvers are obsolete for self-defense carry. He contends they offer no cost advantage over 9mm handguns and are less effective. The speaker suggests larger .357 Magnum revolvers for better recoil management if that caliber is desired, and notes that smaller 9mms exist, though not as compact as .380 ACPs.

Quick Summary

Five-shot .38 Special revolvers are considered obsolete for self-defense carry because they are no longer cheaper than 9mm handguns and offer no compelling advantage. Modern alternatives like 9mm, .380 ACP, and .32 ACP provide better value and performance for concealed carry.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Intro: .357 Magnum in Small Revolvers
  2. 00:22Why 5-Shot .38 Specials Are Obsolete
  3. 01:36Alternatives: Derringers, .32s, .380s, and 9mms

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are five-shot .38 Special revolvers considered obsolete for self-defense carry?

Five-shot .38 Special revolvers are deemed obsolete because they are no longer cheaper than 9mm handguns and offer no significant advantage for self-defense carry in the modern era. There are more effective and cost-efficient options available.

What are better alternatives to a five-shot .38 Special for concealed carry?

For concealed carry, 9mm handguns are often recommended due to their balance of size, capacity, and effectiveness. .380 ACP and .32 ACP are also options for very compact carry, though 9mm offers more power.

If I want to shoot .357 Magnum, what kind of revolver should I consider?

If you want to shoot .357 Magnum and are concerned about recoil in a small frame, a larger .357 Magnum revolver is recommended. This will help manage recoil better and ensure the firearm's longevity.

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →