Archaic Cartridges for Modern People — GMP #291

Published on July 11, 2025
Duration: 38:48

This episode of the Guns Magazine podcast explores the enduring appeal of 'archaic' cartridges for modern shooters. Hosts Brent Wheat and Roy Huntington discuss why cartridges over a century old, such as the .44-40, .25-20, and .45 Colt, remain popular and effective. They argue against the 'fear of missing out' (FOMO) driving constant new cartridge development, emphasizing that proven designs offer value, historical connection, and reliable performance. The discussion highlights that these older cartridges are not obsolete but rather classics that continue to serve their purpose.

Quick Summary

Many 'archaic' cartridges like the .45 Colt, .44-40, and .25-20 remain popular and effective due to their proven performance and historical significance. The firearms industry often pushes new cartridges driven by 'FOMO,' but these classic designs offer reliability and a connection to shooting heritage, proving their enduring value for modern enthusiasts.

Chapters

  1. 00:04Introduction to Guns Magazine Podcast
  2. 00:19Guest Roy Huntington and Topic Introduction
  3. 00:54Sponsor: Arms Corps and Rock Island Armory
  4. 01:35Roy Huntington Joins the Discussion
  5. 02:26Fountain Pens as an Analogy for Old Technology
  6. 02:42Why Shoot Archaic Cartridges?
  7. 03:05Marlin 1894 Rifle and .25-20 Cartridge
  8. 03:18.30-30 Winchester vs. .25-20 Winchester
  9. 03:45The Effectiveness of Older Cartridges
  10. 04:01The 'Fear of Missing Out' (FOMO) Phenomenon
  11. 05:53Defining an Archaic Cartridge
  12. 06:01.45 Colt: A Popular and Enduring Cartridge
  13. 06:26Other Comeback Cartridges: .44-40, .38-40, .32-20
  14. 06:35.22 Hornet: A Classic Varmint Round
  15. 07:16Historical Cartridges and Market Disappearance
  16. 08:10Winchester's Early Cartridge Strategy
  17. 08:57Cartridges with 'Legs': Proven Longevity
  18. 09:14Why Classic Cartridges Still Sell
  19. 10:00Tool Analogy: Harbor Freight Jacks
  20. 10:42FOMO Beyond the Shooting Community
  21. 11:04Fishing Industry Analogy
  22. 12:14Predicting Future Cartridge Longevity
  23. 13:13A Hunter's Perspective on Long-Range Shooting
  24. 14:11.25-20 Cartridge and the Jordan Buck
  25. 15:33Embracing 'Fudness' and Alternative Ways
  26. 17:05Encouraging Open-Mindedness in Shooters
  27. 17:35The History Behind Modern Firearms
  28. 17:54Younger Shooters Discovering Older Guns
  29. 18:39Commentary on Single-Shot Rifles
  30. 19:41Responding to Negative Online Comments
  31. 20:39The Value of Experience in Firearms Knowledge
  32. 21:49The Importance of an Open Mind
  33. 22:26Approaching Disagreements Constructively
  34. 22:31Reflections on a Diverse Gun Collection
  35. 23:36True Experts and Insatiable Curiosity
  36. 24:02The Renaissance Man Approach to Firearms
  37. 25:25Historical Guns and Reloading Challenges
  38. 25:48Hunting Camps and Different Perspectives
  39. 26:16The Legacy and Personality of Firearms
  40. 26:34.25-20 Cartridge and the Jordan Buck Story
  41. 26:55Firearms as Possessions: We Are Caretakers
  42. 27:14The Stories Behind Old Guns
  43. 28:09The Presence of Classic Firearms
  44. 29:011894 Marlin and a Viewer's Comment
  45. 30:19The Panache of Older Firearms vs. Modern Ones
  46. 30:34Nostalgia for Old Tools
  47. 31:51Increased Interest in Antique Cartridges
  48. 33:33Future Interest in Historical Firearms
  49. 34:07Market Potential for Simple Single-Shot Rifles
  50. 34:38The Unlimited Library of Firearms Ideas
  51. 35:04Conclusion: Are Archaic Cartridges Truly Archaic?
  52. 35:27Closing Remarks and Call to Action
  53. 36:27Future Topic: The Ransom Rest
  54. 37:17Housekeeping: Subscribe and Visit Websites
  55. 38:06Sponsor Reminder: Armscore and Rock Island Armory
  56. 38:19Final Sign-off from Brent Wheat

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are older cartridges still popular today?

Older cartridges remain popular because they are proven, effective, and offer a connection to firearms history. Cartridges like the .45 Colt, .44-40, and .32-20 are still manufactured and used for hunting and sport shooting, demonstrating their enduring utility and appeal beyond mere novelty.

What is the 'FOMO' effect in the firearms industry?

FOMO, or 'fear of missing out,' drives the firearms industry to constantly introduce new cartridges and products. This marketing tactic encourages consumers to buy the latest innovations, often overshadowing the continued relevance and effectiveness of established, older designs that still perform exceptionally well.

Can older cartridges like the .25-20 Winchester still be effective for hunting?

Yes, older cartridges can be highly effective. The .25-20 Winchester, for example, is noted for its historical success, including being used to take the 'Jordan buck,' the largest buck in history. This demonstrates that with appropriate use and within its effective range, older cartridges can achieve significant results.

What is the value of exploring 'archaic' firearms and cartridges?

Exploring 'archaic' firearms and cartridges offers a deeper connection to firearms history and legacy. It fosters an appreciation for proven designs, encourages an open mind about different shooting disciplines, and provides a richer, more well-rounded understanding of firearms evolution beyond the latest technological trends.

More General Videos You Might Like

More from GUNS and American Handgunner Magazines

View all →