Colt vs Collier: Patents Lawsuits and Lawyers Oh My!

Published on December 8, 2022
Duration: 17:33

This video delves into the complex history of revolver patents, specifically contrasting the innovations of Elisha Collier with Samuel Colt. It highlights how Colt's success was not solely due to his invention but also his legal team's ability to navigate and, at times, obscure prior art and existing patents. The discussion emphasizes the importance of patents in rewarding innovation, while also acknowledging their potential for abuse through legal maneuvering.

Quick Summary

Elisha Collier developed a functional revolver with integrated cylinder rotation, locking, and priming mechanisms around 1818, predating Samuel Colt's major successes by about 20 years. While Colt is often credited with inventing the modern revolver, his patent success was significantly aided by his legal team's efforts to obscure prior art, including Collier's work.

Chapters

  1. 00:03Introduction: Forgotten Weapons & Professor Ben Nicholson
  2. 00:24Book Pre-Sale: Clockwork Basilisk Kickstarter
  3. 00:41Collier vs. Colt: Common Knowledge vs. Reality
  4. 01:17Collier's Prior Art: 20 Years Before Colt
  5. 01:3917th Century Revolver Mechanisms
  6. 02:48Colt's Patent Challenges: Prior Art and Collier
  7. 03:35Colt's Strategy: Discrediting Collier's Work
  8. 04:37Colt's Research and Influence
  9. 05:06Colt's 1851 Lecture and Prior Art
  10. 05:44Disappearing Guns: The Royal Armouries Connection
  11. 06:46Reasons for Disappearing Evidence
  12. 07:04The 1851/1852 Patent Trials
  13. 07:42Colt Suing Wesson & Leavitt
  14. 08:04Legal Teams and Patent Availability
  15. 08:12The Wheeler US Patent and its Loss
  16. 08:44The French Patent and Translation Issues
  17. 09:08Elisha Collier as a Witness
  18. 09:53Lack of Evidence for Collier's Claims
  19. 10:13Blunt & Sims' Reverse Engineering Attempt
  20. 11:04The Clunky Collier Replica
  21. 11:50Copying the Idea, Not the Patent
  22. 12:00The Power of Patents and Innovation
  23. 13:05The Role of Expensive Lawyers
  24. 13:20Fairness to Sam Colt: Product and Legal Team
  25. 13:54Quality of Colt's Later Revolvers
  26. 14:02Colt's Persistence and Grit
  27. 14:22Colt's Factory Attempts in England
  28. 14:46Persistence in Innovation
  29. 15:01Collier's Lack of Long-Term Persistence
  30. 15:38The Book Project: Persistence and Risk
  31. 16:33Quality of the 'Clockwork Basilisk' Book
  32. 16:45Book Pre-Order and Kickstarter Details
  33. 17:11Conclusion and Thanks

Frequently Asked Questions

Did Elisha Collier invent the revolver before Samuel Colt?

Yes, Elisha Collier developed a functional revolver with integrated cylinder rotation, locking, and priming mechanisms around 1818, approximately 20 years before Samuel Colt's major successes. While Colt is often credited with inventing the modern revolver, Collier's work established key principles earlier.

How did Samuel Colt's legal team influence his patent success?

Colt's legal team played a significant role by actively working to obscure or discredit prior art, including Elisha Collier's patents. They strategically ensured that evidence demonstrating Collier's earlier integrated revolver mechanisms was not presented in patent infringement trials.

What were the 'big three' operations in early revolver development?

The 'big three' operations in early revolver development refer to the integrated mechanical functions of rotating the cylinder to a new chamber, locking the cylinder securely in place, and priming the chamber for firing, typically with percussion caps. Both Collier and earlier designs achieved these.

Were there revolvers with integrated mechanisms before Elisha Collier?

Yes, historical evidence points to revolver mechanisms combining cylinder rotation, alignment, and priming existing as early as the 17th century, around 1660 and 1690. These early weapons featured a hand to advance the cylinder, a stop for alignment, and a priming mechanism, predating both Collier and Colt.

More General Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →