The Guns of Star Wars: Is Disney Getting Lazy?

Published on October 8, 2022
Duration: 8:17

This video analyzes the firearms used in Star Wars: Andor, arguing that the use of real-world surplus firearms like modified AKMS rifles aligns with the franchise's established 'used future' aesthetic. Brandon Herrera details the specific modifications made to the AKMS and compares them to iconic Star Wars props like the E-11 blaster (based on the Sterling SMG) and the DL-44 (based on the Mauser C96). The analysis debunks claims of 'lazy' prop design by highlighting historical precedent and the creative blending of firearm elements.

Quick Summary

The firearms in Star Wars: Andor are modified AKMS underfolder rifles, a choice that aligns with the franchise's established 'used future' aesthetic. Star Wars has historically based its props on real-world firearms, like the Sterling SMG for the E-11 blaster, making this a deliberate design choice.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Intro: Star Wars Guns & Andor Controversy
  2. 00:40AK-47 Backlash in Andor
  3. 01:12Star Wars' History of Real Firearm Props
  4. 02:09Technical Analysis: The 'Space AK' (AKMS)
  5. 03:45MP40 Influence on Prop Design
  6. 05:00Cassian Andor's Blasters Explained
  7. 06:00Conclusion: Prop Design Philosophy

Frequently Asked Questions

What firearms are used as props in Star Wars: Andor?

The primary firearms seen in Star Wars: Andor are modified AKMS underfolder rifles. These are based on real-world Kalashnikov variants and have undergone specific alterations to their furniture, barrel, and receiver for the show's aesthetic.

Why did fans react negatively to the AK-47s in the Andor trailer?

Some fans felt that the visible use of recognizable firearms like the AK-47 in the Andor trailer broke immersion, arguing it contradicted the futuristic setting. However, the show uses modified AKMS variants, aligning with Star Wars' tradition of using real-world guns as prop bases.

Does Star Wars always use real firearms for its props?

Yes, Star Wars has consistently used real-world firearms as the basis for its iconic props since the original trilogy. Examples include the Sterling SMG for the E-11 blaster and the Mauser C96 for Han Solo's DL-44 blaster.

Is using real firearms for sci-fi props considered lazy design?

According to firearms expert Brandon Herrera, using real-world surplus firearms fits the established 'used future' aesthetic of Star Wars. This practice, dating back to the original films, is a deliberate design choice rather than laziness.

Related News

All News →

More General Videos You Might Like

More from Brandon Herrera

View all →