Practical Pistol Show 141 - Still no hopkins

Published on April 16, 2016
Duration: 21:41

This discussion from the Practical Pistol Show features Ben Stoeger, Nick, and Tim Myers comparing IDPA and USPSA shooting sports. They highlight IDPA's slower pace, subjective rules, and scoring model that can hinder speed development for USPSA. While IDPA is seen as a good local club sport with minimal gear requirements, it's generally considered less competitive than USPSA. The speakers also touch on issues like subjective calls and the potential for a 'buddy system' in local matches.

Quick Summary

IDPA and USPSA differ significantly in their approach to competitive shooting. IDPA is often favored for local clubs due to its accessibility, minimal gear requirements, and simpler stage setups, making it easier for new shooters. USPSA, however, is generally considered more competitive, with more complex stages and a scoring model that emphasizes speed and accuracy dynamically, potentially leading to bad habits if a shooter exclusively trains for IDPA.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Question about IDPA
  2. 00:36Listener Question: IDPA vs. USPSA Habits
  3. 01:23Tim Myers' Thoughts on IDPA
  4. 02:23Nick's Thoughts on IDPA and USPSA Differences
  5. 03:51Subjective Rules and Scoring in IDPA
  6. 04:02Nick's Personal Experience with IDPA
  7. 05:05IDPA at the Club Level vs. Regional
  8. 05:52Concerns with IDPA Stage Design and Rules
  9. 06:31Nick as an IDPA Match Director
  10. 07:05IDPA as a Good Local Club Sport
  11. 08:05Potential for Different IDPA Rulebooks
  12. 08:28History of IDPA Rulebook Uproars
  13. 09:21Overall Impression of IDPA as a Sport
  14. 09:43Nick's Departure from IDPA Majors
  15. 10:42IDPA's Place in Competitive Shooting
  16. 11:30Question: Buddy System and Cheating in Local Matches
  17. 12:21Nick's Take on 180 Breaks and Cheating
  18. 13:22Buddy System Cheating in USPSA?
  19. 14:30Tim's View on 180 Breaks and Cheating
  20. 15:08Reluctance to DQ Friends in Local Matches
  21. 15:59Safety Violations vs. Cheating
  22. 16:39RROs and DQing Friends
  23. 17:00Considering Buddy System as Cheating
  24. 17:17Buddies Calling Hits Incorrectly
  25. 17:56Hopkins and Scoring Consistency
  26. 19:06Desire for Scoring Consistency
  27. 19:38Extreme Reaction to Scoring Issues
  28. 20:16Nick's Experience with PBH
  29. 20:50Conclusion and Contact Information

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the main differences between IDPA and USPSA shooting sports?

IDPA is often seen as a more accessible local club sport with simpler stage designs and minimal gear requirements. USPSA, on the other hand, is generally considered more competitive, with more complex stages, stricter rules, and a scoring model that emphasizes speed and accuracy more dynamically.

Can shooting IDPA matches lead to bad habits for USPSA shooters?

Yes, the scoring model in IDPA can prioritize accuracy to a degree that might cause a shooter's speed-related skills like drawing, reloading, and transitioning to suffer if they only train for IDPA. USPSA's rules and scoring encourage a faster pace across all skill sets.

Is the 'buddy system' in local shooting matches considered cheating?

While some view leniency on safety calls like 180-degree breaks as a 'buddy system,' it's often not categorized as outright cheating but rather a reluctance to DQ friends. However, this can lead to shooters developing bad habits that will result in disqualification at higher-level matches.

Why is IDPA considered a good local club sport?

IDPA is favored for local clubs because it has minimal gear requirements, making it easier for new shooters to participate. Stages are also generally simpler and faster to set up compared to USPSA, allowing for more shooting in a shorter timeframe.

Related News

All News →

More Range & Competition Videos You Might Like

More from Ben Stoeger

View all →