10mm SLUGFEST - SIG P220 vs. KIMBER 1911

Published on September 22, 2017
Duration: 37:50

This expert-level review by Justin Opinion meticulously compares the SIG Sauer P220 Elite and the Kimber Stainless Target II, both chambered in 10mm Auto. The analysis includes objective testing of accuracy at 25 yards, trigger pull weights, and a novel grip size metric, demonstrating a high level of technical expertise and methodical evaluation. The SIG P220 Elite ultimately showed superior rested accuracy in this comparison.

Quick Summary

Expert Justin Opinion conducted a detailed 10mm pistol comparison, pitting the SIG Sauer P220 Elite against the Kimber Stainless Target II. His methodical testing revealed the SIG P220 Elite achieved superior rested accuracy at 25 yards (1.303" vs 2.337") and was ergonomically easier to grip based on his 'J.O. Grip Size' metric.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: 10mm Slugfest
  2. 02:01Kimber 1911 Magazines & Mods
  3. 05:44SIG Sauer P220 Elite Overview
  4. 07:04Off-hand Group Comparison
  5. 13:46Spec Comparison & Grip Size
  6. 18:57Rested Accuracy & Trigger Pull Results

Frequently Asked Questions

What were the rested accuracy results for the SIG P220 Elite and Kimber Stainless Target II in 10mm?

In a rested accuracy test at 25 yards, the SIG Sauer P220 Elite achieved a group size of 1.303 inches, while the Kimber Stainless Target II produced a larger group of 2.337 inches, indicating the SIG's superior precision in this scenario.

How did the trigger pulls compare between the SIG P220 Elite and Kimber Stainless Target II?

The trigger pull weights were remarkably similar. The Kimber Stainless Target II averaged 4 lbs 12.2 oz, and the SIG Sauer P220 Elite averaged 4 lbs 14.5 oz, showing minimal difference in this critical performance metric.

What is the 'J.O. Grip Size' metric and what did it reveal about the tested pistols?

The 'J.O. Grip Size' metric multiplies trigger reach by grip thickness to quantify how much hand is needed to wrap around a pistol. The SIG P220 Elite measured 3.15, while the Kimber Stainless Target II measured 3.49, suggesting the SIG is ergonomically easier to grip.

Which 10mm pistol performed better in the off-hand shooting test?

During the off-hand shooting test at 13 yards, both the SIG Sauer P220 Elite and the Kimber Stainless Target II produced very comparable groups. The reviewer concluded this specific test was a draw between the two firearms.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Justin Opinion

View all →