เปรียบเทียบ​.17Hmr VS .22Magnum

Published on February 3, 2023
Duration: 21:05

This video provides an expert comparison between the .17 HMR and .22 Magnum calibers, featuring Naaming Kotchanok, a recognized firearms reviewer in Thailand. The comparison covers performance at various distances (50m, 100m, 150m, 200m) using pineapple targets and paper, detailing bullet drop, accuracy, and impact energy. The .17 HMR demonstrates a flatter trajectory and higher velocity, while the .22 Magnum offers more impact energy and significantly lower ammunition costs, making it the recommended choice for most users in Thailand due to its cost-effectiveness and availability.

Quick Summary

The .17 HMR offers a flatter trajectory and higher velocity, while the .22 Magnum delivers more impact energy and is significantly more cost-effective and available in Thailand. At 150m, .17 HMR drops ~5 inches vs .22 Magnum's ~6 inches (4 MOA). For most users, the .22 Magnum is recommended due to its value.

Chapters

  1. 00:13Introduction & Comparison Goal
  2. 00:52Cartridge Visual Comparison
  3. 01:3550-Meter Pineapple Test
  4. 03:53100-Meter Test & Accuracy
  5. 09:22150-Meter Test & Bullet Drop
  6. 14:49200-Meter Long Range Test
  7. 19:55Conclusion & Recommendation

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between .17 HMR and .22 Magnum cartridges?

.17 HMR offers higher velocity and a flatter trajectory due to its lighter, aerodynamic bullet. The .22 Magnum uses a heavier projectile, providing more impact energy at closer ranges and significantly lower ammunition costs, making it more accessible.

How does the bullet drop compare between .17 HMR and .22 Magnum at longer ranges?

At 150 meters, the .17 HMR has an approximate drop of 5 inches, while the .22 Magnum drops about 6 inches (4 MOA). At 200 meters, the .17 HMR maintains better accuracy and requires less holdover due to its flatter trajectory.

Which caliber is more cost-effective for shooting in Thailand?

The .22 Magnum is considerably more cost-effective in Thailand, with ammunition being roughly 50% cheaper and much easier to find compared to the .17 HMR. This makes it the recommended choice for most general shooting applications.

What performance differences were observed in the pineapple tests?

In the 50-meter pineapple test, the .22 Magnum showed more immediate destructive power, splitting the target. The .17 HMR passed through with high velocity but less apparent expansion on that specific test medium.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Naaming Kotchanok

View all →