600-dollar US Army Pistol VS 10,000-dollar US Army Pistol

Published on January 28, 2025
Duration: 15:48

This video features hickok45 comparing a $600 Cimarron replica of the Colt Cavalry Model with an original 1883 Colt Cavalry model, both chambered in .45 Long Colt. The expert instructor highlights the historical significance and authentication processes for antique firearms, emphasizing the value of expert verification like a 'Kopec letter' for high-value pieces. He demonstrates the reliable performance of the modern replica while also showcasing the unique experience of firing the original with black powder, stressing the importance of immediate cleaning after such use.

Quick Summary

A $600 Cimarron replica of the Colt Cavalry Model is compared to an original 1883 Colt Cavalry pistol valued over $10,000. Expert instructor hickok45 highlights that while replicas offer accessible shooting experiences, originals command high prices due to age, US Army provenance, rarity, and condition. He stresses the importance of expert authentication for valuable antiques.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Replica vs. Original
  2. 00:33Visual Comparison: 'U.S.' Markings
  3. 03:41Shooting the Cimarron Replica
  4. 05:05Antique Value Factors
  5. 08:06Importance of Expert Authentication
  6. 09:06Shooting the Original 1883 Colt
  7. 11:41Conclusion: History vs. Modernity

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the price difference between the Cimarron replica and the original 1883 Colt Cavalry pistol?

The Cimarron replica of the Colt Cavalry Model is priced at approximately $600, while an original 1883 Colt Cavalry pistol, due to its historical significance and rarity, can command a value exceeding $10,000.

Why is expert authentication important for antique firearms like the 1883 Colt?

Expert authentication, often documented in letters from specialists like John Kopec, is vital for verifying the originality of parts, confirming historical provenance, and establishing the true value of high-end antique firearms, preventing misrepresentation.

What are the key factors contributing to the high value of an original 1883 Colt Cavalry pistol?

The high value of an original 1883 Colt Cavalry pistol is driven by its age, its status as a US Army issue firearm, its rarity in good condition, and its overall historical significance as a piece of American military history.

What is the main difference in shooting experience between a modern replica and an antique black powder revolver?

Modern replicas like the Cimarron offer reliable performance for contemporary shooting. Antique black powder revolvers, like the 1883 Colt, provide a historically immersive experience, including characteristic smoke and the need for immediate post-firing cleaning.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from hickok45

View all →