Beretta M38A vs Suomi kp/31 (w/ John Keene)

Published on November 4, 2024
Duration: 10:42

This video features retired Master Sergeant and NFA expert John Keene, alongside Ian McCollum, comparing the iconic WWII submachine guns, the Beretta M38A and the Suomi KP/31. Keene, with 40 years of experience, provides an expert analysis of their mechanical features, operational simplicity, logistical advantages, and combat effectiveness. The discussion highlights the Suomi's high rate of fire and capacity versus the Beretta's ease of use and magazine handling, offering insights valuable for collectors and firearm enthusiasts.

Quick Summary

NFA expert John Keene compares the Beretta M38A and Suomi KP/31, highlighting the Suomi's high rate of fire and capacity versus the Beretta's simpler operation and easier magazine changes. Keene prefers the Suomi for combat due to confidence at range, while noting the Beretta's logistical advantages and the rarity of Suomis in the US.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Beretta M38A vs Suomi KP/31
  2. 00:35Physical Comparison of SMGs
  3. 01:53Collector Selection Criteria
  4. 03:51Mechanical Advantages of Suomi
  5. 05:08Combat Preference and Range
  6. 06:29Beretta Operational Simplicity
  7. 07:34Magazine Changes and Logistics
  8. 09:05Scarcity and US Market

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the Beretta M38A and the Suomi KP/31?

The Beretta M38A is lighter, uses lower-capacity box magazines, and fires slower, while the Suomi KP/31 has a very high rate of fire and high-capacity drum magazines. The Beretta's dual triggers are simpler under stress, but the Suomi's detachable barrel aids maintenance.

Which submachine gun does NFA expert John Keene prefer for combat?

John Keene expresses higher confidence in the Suomi KP/31 for combat scenarios, citing its effectiveness at greater distances and overall reliability in his extensive experience with machine guns.

Why are Suomi KP/31 submachine guns rare in the US?

Suomi KP/31s are extremely rare in the United States because American troops rarely encountered Finnish forces during WWII, limiting the opportunities to bring them back as trophies or souvenirs.

What are the logistical advantages of the Beretta M38A over the Suomi KP/31?

The Beretta M38A offers significant advantages in magazine change speed and ease of carrying stick magazines. This contrasts with the Suomi KP/31's bulkier drum magazines, which can be more cumbersome in rapid logistical operations.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →