Videos tagged with John Keene

This video features an expert discussion comparing the M2 Carbine and the MP44 Sturmgewehr for modern infantry roles, considering logistical support. John Keene favors the MP44 for its superior intermediate cartridge and ergonomics, while Ian McCollum prefers the lighter, handier M2 Carbine, arguing ballistic differences are marginal at typical engagement ranges. The discussion covers reliability, environmental resistance, and operational considerations like prone shooting.

This review compares the M2 Carbine and the MP44 Sturmgewehr, highlighting differing expert opinions on their combat effectiveness. John Keene favors the MP44 for its armor-piercing capabilities and ergonomics, while Ian McCollum argues for the M2 Carbine's lighter weight and handiness. Both acknowledge the practical irrelevance of long-range accuracy in modern warfare.

This review compares the iconic WWII submachine guns, the German MP-40 and Soviet PPSh-41. While the MP-40 offers better ergonomics and a slower, more controllable rate of fire favored by beginners, the PPSh-41 excels in raw firepower with higher velocity and capacity. Both have distinct design philosophies, with the MP-40 prioritizing portability for troops and the PPSh-41 focusing on mass production and effectiveness.

This comparison between the MP-40 and PPSh-41 highlights differing design philosophies. John Keene favors the MP-40 for its ergonomics and adaptations for higher magazine capacity, while Ian McCollum prefers the PPSh-41 for its high rate of fire and semi-auto selector. Both speakers acknowledge the controllability of their preferred weapon despite its characteristics.

This comparison between the G1 (FAL) and G3 (H&K) focuses on military utility. John Keene prefers the G3 for its lighter weight, while Ian McCollum favors the G1 for its left-hand friendliness and modularity for rifle grenades. The G3's roller-delayed blowback and synthetic furniture offer advantages in durability and environmental resistance over the G1's adjustable gas system and wood components.

This video compares the FN FAL (G1) and H&K G3 battle rifles, with John Keene favoring the G3 for its lighter weight and Ian McCollum preferring the FAL for its left-hand friendly charging handle. Both rifles are acknowledged as top-tier military firearms with extensive service histories. The discussion highlights specific ergonomic differences, such as the FAL's charging handle placement versus the G3's overall lighter carry weight.

In this comparison of the Valmet M78 and FN Model D light machine guns, John Keene and Ian McCollum debate their military utility. Keene favors the FN-D for its quick-change barrel and robust design, while McCollum leans towards the Valmet M78 for its inherent reliability and lighter weight. Both experts acknowledge that soldier proficiency can overcome weapon limitations.

This review compares the Valmet M78 and FN-D light machine guns, with John Keene favoring the FN-D due to its quick-change barrel feature. Ian McCollum raises a practical point about the necessity of barrel changes versus ammunition capacity. Ultimately, both firearms are recognized as excellent, with the choice depending on specific tactical priorities.

The Sten MkII is presented as a benchmark for functional submachine guns, with any design failing if it's not clearly superior. The MAC M10/9 is critiqued for its top-heavy feel and poor stock. For range use and hypothetical combat, the Sten is preferred due to easier magazine loading, better parts availability, controllable fire rate, superior sights, and better stock handling. Aftermarket conversions like Lage's have significantly improved the MAC's practicality.

This video features a comparison between two iconic submachine guns: the Beretta M38A and the Suomi KP/31, hosted by John Keene. The title and description explicitly mention these specific firearm models and hint at a comparative analysis, suggesting a deep dive into their features and performance. The inclusion of hashtags like #forgottenweapons and #smg indicates a focus on historical and collectible firearms, likely with expert commentary.

This expert-level review compares the Beretta M38A and Suomi KP/31 submachine guns, drawing on the extensive experience of NFA expert John Keene. Keene, a retired Master Sergeant with 40 years of experience, provides insights into collector value, operational differences, and combat effectiveness. The comparison highlights the Suomi's higher rate of fire and magazine capacity versus the Beretta's simpler operation and faster magazine changes, offering a nuanced view for firearms enthusiasts and collectors.

This video features Ian from Forgotten Weapons and NFA specialist John Keene discussing how original US military machine guns become available on the civilian market. They differentiate between models that are commonly found in original condition, like the Reising, and those that are rare in original form, often appearing as parts kits built on new receivers, such as the Browning 1917 and 1919. The discussion aims to explain the factors driving these market availabilities.