Videos tagged with John Keene

This video features a comparison between the Franchi LF-57 and the Colt SMG, hosted by Ian McCollum and John Keene. They discuss the pros and cons of each submachine gun, considering factors like ergonomics, reliability, parts availability, and collectibility. While the Colt SMG is technically superior in many shooting aspects, the Franchi LF-57 is favored for its rarity and unique appeal as a collectible item.

This expert analysis compares the M2 Carbine and MP44 Sturmgewehr for a modern infantry role, drawing on insights from firearms experts Ian McCollum and John Keene. Key considerations include cartridge effectiveness, weight, reliability in various conditions, ergonomics, and market value, highlighting trade-offs between the two iconic firearms. The discussion emphasizes practical engagement ranges and operational nuances relevant to military applications.

This expert comparison, featuring John Keene, delves into the nuances of the MP-40 and PPSh-41 submachine guns. It highlights their distinct design philosophies, focusing on ergonomics, rate of fire, magazine capacity, and stock design. The discussion also touches upon their historical battlefield preferences and current market values, offering a comprehensive overview for firearm enthusiasts.

This comparison between the MP-40 and PPSh-41 highlights differing design philosophies. John Keene favors the MP-40 for its ergonomics and adaptations for higher magazine capacity, while Ian McCollum prefers the PPSh-41 for its high rate of fire and semi-auto selector. Both speakers acknowledge the controllability of their preferred weapon despite its characteristics.

This expert analysis from Forgotten Weapons, featuring John Keene, a retired Master Sergeant and NFA expert, compares the G1 (FAL) and G3 (H&K) rifles for military utility. Keene favors the G3 for its lighter weight, while McCollum prefers the G1 for its left-hand friendly charging handle and rifle grenade capability. The discussion highlights the G3's modern civilian modularity and superior durability in harsh environments due to synthetic furniture, contrasting with the G1's wood and leather components.

This video features John Keene and Ian McCollum discussing the merits of the FN FAL (G1) and the H&K G3 battle rifles. Keene favors the G3 for its lighter carrying weight, while McCollum leans towards the FAL due to its more left-hand friendly charging handle, despite acknowledging the FAL's selector switch can be accidentally bumped. Both rifles are recognized as top-tier battle rifles with extensive military service histories.

In this comparison of the Valmet M78 and FN Model D light machine guns, John Keene and Ian McCollum debate their military utility. Keene favors the FN-D for its quick-change barrel and robust design, while McCollum leans towards the Valmet M78 for its inherent reliability and lighter weight. Both experts acknowledge that soldier proficiency can overcome weapon limitations.

This review compares the Valmet M78 and FN-D light machine guns, with John Keene favoring the FN-D due to its quick-change barrel feature. Ian McCollum raises a practical point about the necessity of barrel changes versus ammunition capacity. Ultimately, both firearms are recognized as excellent, with the choice depending on specific tactical priorities.

This video features firearms historian Ian McCollum and John Keene comparing the Sten MkII and the MAC M10/9. They analyze the strengths and weaknesses of each platform, discussing their utility for range use, hypothetical combat scenarios, and overall value. Keene favors the Sten for its practical handling and controllability, while McCollum notes the significant improvements made to the MAC platform through aftermarket modifications like Lage uppers. The discussion highlights the Sten's role as a benchmark for SMG design.

This video features a comparison between two iconic submachine guns: the Beretta M38A and the Suomi KP/31, hosted by John Keene. The title and description explicitly mention these specific firearm models and hint at a comparative analysis, suggesting a deep dive into their features and performance. The inclusion of hashtags like #forgottenweapons and #smg indicates a focus on historical and collectible firearms, likely with expert commentary.

This video features retired Master Sergeant and NFA expert John Keene, alongside Ian McCollum, comparing the iconic WWII submachine guns, the Beretta M38A and the Suomi KP/31. Keene, with 40 years of experience, provides an expert analysis of their mechanical features, operational simplicity, logistical advantages, and combat effectiveness. The discussion highlights the Suomi's high rate of fire and capacity versus the Beretta's ease of use and magazine handling, offering insights valuable for collectors and firearm enthusiasts.

This guide details a practical test of different .303 British ammunition types in a 1914 Lewis Gun, as demonstrated by Ian McCollum. It highlights how surplus ammunition quality can vary significantly, impacting firearm reliability. The test reveals that while some surplus (like Greek HXP) performs flawlessly, others (British WWII and Pakistani POF) can cause frequent malfunctions, underscoring the importance of selecting quality ammunition for reliable firearm operation.