Best Allied SMG of WW2? (Owen vs Thompson vs Grease Gun)

Published on October 31, 2022
Duration: 31:22

This video provides an expert-level comparison of three iconic Allied SMGs from WWII: the Owen Machine Carbine, the Thompson SMG, and the M3 Grease Gun. The host, demonstrating high authority and deep technical knowledge, analyzes their historical context, mechanical designs, handling, reliability, and concludes the Owen Machine Carbine is the superior combat SMG, while the Thompson is favored by collectors.

Quick Summary

The Owen Machine Carbine is deemed the best combat SMG for WWII due to its exceptional reliability and ergonomics, featuring a sealed action and gravity-assisted ejection. The Thompson SMG, while less practical for combat, is the top choice for collectors owing to its iconic status and craftsmanship.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Question of the Day
  2. 02:53Thompson SMG History and Variants
  3. 05:53M3 Grease Gun Overview
  4. 06:44Owen Machine Carbine History
  5. 08:18Manipulation and Controls
  6. 10:11Reloading Mechanics
  7. 11:51Handling and Ergonomics
  8. 15:53Reliability and Field Performance
  9. 17:12Final Verdict

Frequently Asked Questions

Which WWII Allied SMG is considered the best for combat?

The Owen Machine Carbine is highlighted as the best combat SMG due to its superior reliability, stemming from a sealed action and gravity-assisted downward ejection that prevents dirt ingress and facilitates easy malfunction clearance. Its ergonomics also contribute to its effectiveness in the field.

What makes the Thompson SMG a favorite among collectors?

The Thompson SMG, particularly the 1928 'gangster' model, is highly prized by collectors for its exceptional craftsmanship, iconic status in popular culture, and significant historical role. Its distinctive design and association with historical events make it a sought-after piece.

What are the main drawbacks of the M3 Grease Gun?

While designed for cost-effective mass production, the M3 Grease Gun has several drawbacks, including notoriously difficult-to-load single-feed magazines and awkward handling characteristics. Its stamped metal construction and simpler design also make it less appealing to collectors compared to the Thompson.

How does the Owen Machine Carbine's design contribute to its reliability?

The Owen Machine Carbine's reliability is significantly enhanced by its open-bolt, blowback operation combined with a sealed action. This design prevents dirt and debris from entering the mechanism, while gravity-assisted downward ejection helps clear any potential malfunctions smoothly.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Arm&Gun

View all →