Does Size Matter? | Gun Cranks

Published on October 8, 2020
Duration: 45:00

This discussion from Gun Cranks explores the age-old question of whether 'size matters' in concealed carry firearms. The hosts, editors from GUNS and American Handgunner Magazines, debate the trade-offs between concealability and shootability. They emphasize that while smaller guns are easier to hide, larger firearms often provide better control, accuracy, and a more comfortable shooting experience, especially for newer shooters. The consensus leans towards choosing a firearm that balances concealability with the shooter's ability to effectively operate and shoot it under stress, highlighting the importance of reliability and personal preference.

Quick Summary

The debate on firearm size for concealed carry highlights a trade-off between concealability and shootability. While smaller guns are easier to hide, larger firearms often provide better control, accuracy, and comfort, especially for new shooters. Modern reliability means focusing on personal preference and the ability to shoot accurately.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction to Gun Cranks
  2. 01:39The 'Size Doesn't Matter' Debate
  3. 02:21Arguments for Larger Carry Guns
  4. 03:20Historical Pocket Nine Millimeters
  5. 07:25Modern Subcompacts: Hellcat & P365
  6. 09:40Comfort and Shootability of Medium Guns
  7. 10:30Concealment Methods & Holsters
  8. 12:00Maintenance for IWB Carry
  9. 14:50Advice for First-Time Buyers
  10. 16:00The 'Getaway Gun' Concept
  11. 18:00Revolving Carry Choices & Evolution
  12. 20:00Big Bore Revolvers for Carry?
  13. 21:30Modular Handgun Platforms (SIG P320)
  14. 23:00The Perfect Carry Gun (For Now)
  15. 24:00Final Thoughts: Does Size Matter?
  16. 25:00Closing Remarks & Next Episode

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main argument for carrying a larger concealed firearm?

Larger firearms generally offer better control, a more comfortable grip, and a longer sight radius, which contributes to improved accuracy and easier management of recoil. This makes them more forgiving, especially for newer shooters, and can lead to greater confidence in their ability to shoot accurately under stress.

How does modern manufacturing affect the choice of concealed carry firearm size?

Modern manufacturing has made even subcompact and micro-compact firearms highly reliable. This means that reliability is less of a concern across different sizes, allowing individuals to focus more on personal preference, shootability, and concealability when choosing their everyday carry weapon.

What advice is given for new shooters choosing a concealed carry handgun?

For new shooters, a medium-sized handgun is often recommended. These firearms strike a balance between being concealable and offering better shootability, recoil management, and control compared to very small micro-compacts, making them easier to learn and become proficient with.

Does the method of concealed carry influence the ideal firearm size?

Yes, the method of carry significantly impacts perceived size. While a smaller gun might seem easier to conceal, proper holsters and clothing can make larger firearms manageable for inside-the-waistband (IWB) carry. Conversely, pocket carry inherently favors smaller firearms.

Related News

All News →

More EDC & Lifestyle Videos You Might Like

More from GUNS and American Handgunner Magazines

View all →