Double Stack 1911 Comparison Range Test

Published on May 1, 2024
Duration: 14:25

This video compares four double-stack 1911 pistols: the Bull Armory SAS II Tac, Tisas 1911 Carry, Springfield Armory Prodigy, and Girsan Witness 2311. The instructor conducts two drills: a 7-yard, 5-shot rapid grouping drill for return to zero and comfort, and a 7-yard, 6-shot rapid fire drill from a barrel for control and trigger speed. The results highlight differences in weight balance, trigger feel, and shooter adaptation.

Quick Summary

A range test compared four double-stack 1911 pistols: Bull Armory SAS II Tac, Tisas 1911 Carry, Springfield Armory Prodigy, and Girsan Witness 2311. Drills focused on rapid grouping for return to zero and speed shooting for control. The Prodigy shot flat due to its weight, while the Bull Armory felt most natural with a superior trigger. The Tisas experienced red dot sight issues.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Pistol Lineup
  2. 00:19Pistols Featured: Bull Armory, Tisas, Springfield, Girsan
  3. 01:00Testing Methodology: Drills Explained
  4. 01:30Drill 1: 7-Yard Rapid Grouping
  5. 02:00Drill 2: 7-Yard Rapid Fire from Barrel
  6. 02:53Optics vs. Irons: Variable Setup
  7. 03:30Tisas Rear Sight Issue & Red Dot Install
  8. 04:05Ammunition Used: Fiocchi 9 AP
  9. 04:36Bull Armory SAS II Tac: Grouping Test
  10. 05:11Bull Armory SAS II Tac: Speed Drill
  11. 06:35Springfield Armory Prodigy: Grouping Test
  12. 07:25Springfield Armory Prodigy: Speed Drill
  13. 08:36Girsan Witness 2311: Grouping Test
  14. 09:26Girsan Witness 2311: Speed Drill
  15. 10:18Tisas 1911 Carry: Grouping Test (Dot Issues)
  16. 10:50Tisas 1911 Carry: Speed Drill (Irons)
  17. 11:00Tisas Dot Sight Performance Issues
  18. 12:05Tisas 1911 Carry: Overall Performance
  19. 12:31Instructor's Overall Impressions & Favorites
  20. 13:01Impact of Shooter Experience Bias
  21. 13:26Noticeable Performance Differences
  22. 13:58Conclusion: Differences May Be Smaller Than Perceived
  23. 14:10Final Thoughts & Viewer Engagement

Frequently Asked Questions

What drills were used to compare the double-stack 1911 pistols?

Two drills were conducted: a 7-yard, 5-shot rapid grouping drill to assess return to zero and comfort, and a 7-yard, 6-shot rapid fire drill from a barrel to evaluate control at speed and trigger management.

How did the Springfield Armory Prodigy perform in the range test?

The Prodigy's steel frame and nose weight made it shoot flat and feel steady, though its heft was noted as potentially less ideal for concealed carry. It achieved a total time of 3:33 for the speed drill, with the first shot at 1.85 seconds.

What issues were encountered with the Tisas 1911 Carry during the test?

The Tisas 1911 Carry had a crooked rear sight from the factory, requiring an aftermarket red dot. During the test, the red dot sight became obscured, forcing the instructor to switch to iron sights, impacting performance and accuracy.

Which double-stack 1911 felt the most natural to the instructor?

The Bull Armory SAS II Tac felt the most natural to the instructor due to his familiarity with the firearm. He also found it to be the best balanced for carry and noted its crisper, shorter, and lighter trigger pull compared to others.

Related News

All News โ†’

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from GBGuns

View all โ†’