Federal Punch vs Winchester Silvertip .22 Magnum Ballistic Gel Test Review .22WMR

Published on March 1, 2024
Duration: 18:08

This video presents a ballistic gelatin test comparing Federal Punch and Winchester Silvertip .22 WMR ammunition fired from a Taurus 942 pistol with a 3-inch barrel. The test focuses on penetration depth, wound cavity creation, and bullet expansion. The presenter notes that neither ammunition expanded significantly from the short barrel, but both demonstrated tumbling, creating notable wound channels. The Federal Punch generally outperformed the Winchester Silvertip in terms of wound cavity size and consistent tumbling.

Quick Summary

In a ballistic gelatin test with a 3-inch barrel Taurus 942, neither Federal Punch nor Winchester Silvertip .22 WMR expanded. Both rounds tumbled, creating significant wound channels, with Federal Punch showing a larger cavity and more consistent tumbling than Winchester Silvertip.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: .22 WMR Gel Test
  2. 00:20Test Setup: Taurus 942 & Gelatin Calibration
  3. 02:30Winchester Silvertip Test - Shot 1
  4. 04:05Winchester Silvertip Test - Shot 2
  5. 05:57Federal Punch Test - Shot 1
  6. 07:15Federal Punch Test - Shot 2
  7. 09:08Clothing Test: 4 Layers Denim
  8. 09:21Denim Test: Winchester Silvertip & Federal Punch
  9. 10:25Denim Test: Final Winchester Silvertip Shot
  10. 13:37Projectile Analysis: Weight & Diameter
  11. 15:07Ammunition Close-Up: Punch vs. Silvertip Design
  12. 16:08Conclusion: Barrel Length & Expansion
  13. 17:11Future Tests & Video Links

Frequently Asked Questions

Did Federal Punch or Winchester Silvertip .22 WMR expand in the ballistic gel test?

Neither the Federal Punch nor the Winchester Silvertip .22 WMR ammunition expanded significantly when fired from a 3-inch pistol barrel into ballistic gelatin. The test indicated that shorter barrels may not provide enough velocity for reliable hollow-point expansion with these rounds.

How did Federal Punch .22 WMR perform in the ballistic gel test?

The Federal Punch .22 WMR created a larger wound channel and demonstrated consistent tumbling, even without expansion, when fired from a 3-inch pistol barrel. It generally outperformed the Winchester Silvertip in terms of wound cavity size and projectile behavior.

What was the effect of clothing layers on .22 WMR ammunition performance in the gel test?

Testing with four layers of denim showed minimal impact on the performance of Federal Punch and Winchester Silvertip .22 WMR. Neither round expanded through the denim, and the tumbling effect remained consistent, suggesting clothing did not significantly alter their terminal ballistics from this platform.

What firearm was used for the .22 WMR ballistic gelatin test?

The ballistic gelatin tests were conducted using a Taurus 942 ultralight revolver, specifically noted to have a 3-inch barrel. This barrel length is a key factor in the observed performance, particularly regarding bullet expansion.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Buckeye Ballistics

View all →