Girsan 1911 Chapter 2 - Reliable?

Published on December 17, 2019
Duration: 22:46

This video is a follow-up review of the Girsan MC1911 pistol, focusing on its reliability with different ammunition types after an initial break-in period. The presenter tests 100 rounds of Full Metal Jacket (FMJ) and various hollow-point (HP) ammunition, encountering persistent issues primarily attributed to the firearm's extractor claw, not the ammunition itself. The review highlights the importance of proper extractor function for reliable feeding and ejection, especially with HP rounds.

Quick Summary

The Girsan MC1911 experienced reliability issues, primarily with hollow-point ammunition, due to its extractor claw failing to properly engage cartridge rims. After testing various ammunitions, the presenter concluded the issue lies with the firearm's extractor, not the ammo, suggesting extractor tuning as a potential fix.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction & Recap
  2. 00:31Ammunition Selection
  3. 01:38Magazine Performance Check
  4. 02:13FMJ Ammunition Test
  5. 04:06Freedom Munitions Test
  6. 05:37Switching to Known Good Mags
  7. 08:20Federal HST Hollow Point Test
  8. 10:37Slide Release Technique Observation
  9. 12:52Extractor Claw Malfunction Analysis
  10. 15:36Hornady Ammunition Test
  11. 17:59Extractor Claw Issue Persists
  12. 22:28Conclusion & Part 3 Tease

Frequently Asked Questions

What were the main reliability issues encountered with the Girsan MC1911 in this follow-up review?

The Girsan MC1911 experienced persistent hang-ups, particularly with hollow-point ammunition. The primary cause identified was the extractor claw failing to properly engage the rim of the cartridge, leading to feeding and ejection malfunctions.

Was the ammunition the cause of the Girsan MC1911's malfunctions?

No, the presenter concluded that the ammunition was likely not the primary cause. Despite testing various brands and types of hollow points and FMJ rounds, the malfunctions consistently pointed to an issue with the firearm's extractor claw.

What potential solution was suggested for the Girsan MC1911's reliability problems?

Based on viewer comments and the observed malfunction, the presenter suggested that tuning the extractor claw might resolve the reliability issues. This involves ensuring the claw properly goes over the cartridge rim for reliable extraction.

Did the ProMag magazines perform reliably with the Girsan MC1911?

No, the ProMag magazine used in the test did not hold open after the last round. This was identified as a known issue with ProMag magazines on 1911 platforms, indicating it was not a fault of the Girsan MC1911 itself.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Buckeye Ballistics

View all →