Glock 43X vs. M&P Shield vs. SIG P365

Published on February 9, 2019
Duration: 41:51

This video provides a detailed head-to-head comparison of three popular micro-compact 9mm concealed carry handguns: the Glock 43X, Smith & Wesson M&P Shield, and SIG P365. The presenter, Justin Opinion, offers objective data on dimensions, weight, trigger pull, and price, alongside subjective shooting impressions and accuracy tests. He highlights key differences in magazine capacity, grip size, and trigger feel, ultimately revealing his personal carry choice.

Quick Summary

The SIG P365 is the most compact 9mm concealed carry pistol, measuring 5.8" in length and 4.3" in height with its flush magazine, while holding 10 rounds standard and 12 extended. The Glock 43X is larger at 6.5" length and 5.04" height, with a 10-round capacity and a comfortable full-size grip. The S&W M&P Shield offers a slim profile with 7/8 round capacity and excellent recoil management.

Chapters

  1. 00:15Introduction & Overview
  2. 00:22Head-to-Head Comparison Setup
  3. 01:07Visual Comparison of Sizes
  4. 01:24Magazine Capacity Differences
  5. 02:41Objective Specifications: Barrel Length, Overall Length
  6. 03:12Objective Specifications: Height
  7. 03:57Objective Specifications: Thickness
  8. 04:17Trigger Pull Weight Measurements
  9. 04:34Grip Index Measurements
  10. 05:00Price Comparison (MSRP)
  11. 05:35Why These Three Guns?
  12. 06:53Ammunition & Range Setup
  13. 08:08Glock 43X Shooting
  14. 08:17M&P Shield Shooting
  15. 09:01SIG P365 Shooting
  16. 11:38Sight Preference & Accuracy Discussion
  17. 11:56Accuracy Test: Paper Targets
  18. 16:36Accuracy Test Results: Glock 43X
  19. 16:52Accuracy Test Results: M&P Shield
  20. 17:11Accuracy Test Results: P365
  21. 17:47Trigger Dynamics: Glock 43X
  22. 19:30Trigger Dynamics: M&P Shield
  23. 21:08Trigger Dynamics: P365
  24. 22:49Visual Comparison: Length & Height
  25. 23:50Shooting Impressions: Glock 43X
  26. 25:25Shooting Impressions: M&P Shield
  27. 27:27Shooting Impressions: P365
  28. 29:06Overall Thoughts & Reliability
  29. 30:38Talon Grips for Glock 43X
  30. 31:0110 Rounds of 9mm: Enough?
  31. 31:40Final Verdict: Glock 43X
  32. 31:49Final Verdict: M&P Shield
  33. 34:10Final Verdict: SIG P365
  34. 37:13No Single 'Winner' Philosophy
  35. 37:44Presenter's Personal Carry Choice
  36. 38:21Thanks & Credits

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the Glock 43X, S&W M&P Shield, and SIG P365 for concealed carry?

The SIG P365 is the smallest and lightest, offering the highest capacity (10/12 rounds). The Glock 43X is the longest and tallest with a 10-round capacity and a comfortable full-size grip. The M&P Shield is a proven, slim option with lower capacity (7/8 rounds) but excellent recoil management and a very slim profile.

Which of these three concealed carry pistols has the best trigger?

The SIG P365 is generally considered to have the best trigger among the three, featuring a light, crisp break and an excellent reset. The Glock 43X also has a good, crisp trigger, while the M&P Shield's trigger is improved but can feel slightly squishy due to its safety mechanism.

How do the magazine capacities compare for the Glock 43X, M&P Shield, and SIG P365?

The Glock 43X comes standard with a 10-round single-stack magazine. The S&W M&P Shield has a standard 7-round flush magazine and an extended 8-round magazine. The SIG P365 offers a standard 10-round magazine and an extended 12-round magazine, providing the highest capacity in the smallest package.

What are the physical dimensions of the Glock 43X, M&P Shield, and SIG P365?

The SIG P365 is the smallest at 5.8" length and 4.3" height (with flush mag). The Glock 43X is the largest at 6.5" length and 5.04" height. The M&P Shield falls in between, with a 6.1" length and 4.45" height (with flush mag).

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Justin Opinion

View all →