Hk VP40 vs STEYR S40-A1

Published on January 13, 2021
Duration: 24:34

This video provides a head-to-head comparison of the Steyr S40-A1 and the HK VP40, both chambered in .40 Smith & Wesson. The reviewer, Justin Opinion, details shooting impressions, technical specifications, and ergonomic differences. While the VP40 is noted as a larger, more full-sized duty gun with superior ergonomics and a slightly heavier trigger pull, the S40-A1, despite its unique sights and a history of early malfunctions, demonstrated superior accuracy in this test, producing a tighter group. The video highlights key differences in grip tang design, bore axis, and magazine release mechanisms, ultimately concluding that personal preference dictates the better choice.

Quick Summary

The Steyr S40-A1 and HK VP40, both in .40 Smith & Wesson, offer distinct advantages. The VP40 is a larger duty gun with superior ergonomics and a paddle mag release, while the S40-A1, though smaller and discontinued, proved more accurate in testing with unique pyramid sights and a lighter trigger pull.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: VP40 vs Steyr S40-A1
  2. 00:27Shooting the Steyr S40-A1
  3. 01:47Shooting the HK VP40
  4. 02:13Steyr Sights Explained
  5. 03:40HK VP40 Overview
  6. 05:03Head-to-Head Target Practice
  7. 05:2812-Yard Target Comparison Setup
  8. 05:43Steyr S40-A1 Target Shooting
  9. 07:17HK VP40 Target Shooting
  10. 08:43Target Group Analysis
  11. 09:16Comparing .40 Caliber Pistols
  12. 09:54Size and Ergonomic Differences
  13. 11:10Height and Grip Comparison
  14. 11:36Grip Angles and Tang Design
  15. 12:20Magazine Capacity
  16. 12:44Trigger Pull Measurements
  17. 13:10Grip Index Measurement
  18. 14:14Magazine Release and Slide Features
  19. 14:52Steyr Locking Mechanism
  20. 15:12Trigger Guard Size
  21. 15:23Sight Design Comparison
  22. 16:00Discontinued Model: Steyr S40-A1
  23. 16:49Accuracy Test Results
  24. 17:26Final Thoughts and Range Wrap-up
  25. 17:40Reviewer's Experience with Steyr
  26. 18:13Reviewer's Affection for VP40
  27. 18:55Sights: Glow-in-the-Dark vs. Standard
  28. 19:29Picking a Winner: Pros and Cons
  29. 19:35VP40 vs. S40-A1: Enjoyment vs. Accuracy
  30. 20:09Steyr Accuracy and Ergonomics
  31. 21:04Personal Preference Conclusion
  32. 21:40Final Magazines and Day's End

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the Steyr S40-A1 and the HK VP40?

The HK VP40 is a larger, full-sized duty gun with superior ergonomics and a paddle magazine release. The Steyr S40-A1 is smaller, features unique pyramid sights, and demonstrated better accuracy in testing, though it's a discontinued model. Key differences also include grip tang design, trigger pull weight, and trigger guard size.

How do the sights on the Steyr S40-A1 and HK VP40 compare?

The Steyr S40-A1 has distinctive white pyramid front and hollow pyramid rear sights, which some find intuitive. The HK VP40 uses standard sights with glow-in-the-dark elements, which the reviewer finds less useful than true night sights. Both have Novak-style rear sights.

Which pistol, the Steyr S40-A1 or HK VP40, is more accurate?

In the reviewer's test at 12 yards, the Steyr S40-A1 shot a tighter group, measuring 1.166 inches, while the HK VP40's group measured 2.096 inches. This suggests the Steyr S40-A1 may be more accurate, despite the VP40's generally favorable ergonomics.

What are the trigger pull weights for the Steyr S40-A1 and HK VP40?

The Steyr S40-A1 has a trigger pull of approximately 4 pounds 7.5 ounces, just under four and a half pounds. The HK VP40's trigger pull is heavier, measuring 5 pounds 2 ounces. Both are considered good trigger pulls, but the Steyr's is notably lighter.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Justin Opinion

View all →