Hopkins & Allen XL No.8: A Failed Competitor to the Colt SAA

Published on April 27, 2020
Duration: 8:42

The Hopkins & Allen XL No.8 was an ambitious attempt to enter the high-end revolver market, directly challenging the Colt SAA and Smith & Wesson Model 3. Despite its quality construction, influenced by Merwin & Hulbert designs, it failed commercially due to the company's reputation for inexpensive firearms. Production ceased in 1885, making these revolvers rare today.

Quick Summary

The Hopkins & Allen XL No.8 was an ambitious attempt to challenge the Colt SAA and S&W Model 3 in the high-end revolver market. Despite quality construction influenced by Merwin & Hulbert, it failed commercially due to Hopkins & Allen's reputation for inexpensive firearms.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Hopkins & Allen Company History
  2. 01:25XL No.8 Market Positioning vs Colt SAA
  3. 02:15Design Influences from Merwin & Hulbert
  4. 03:40XL No.8 Models and Calibers Explained
  5. 04:51Unique Ejector Rod Mechanism
  6. 06:35Commercial Failure and Rarity

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the Hopkins & Allen XL No.8 designed to compete with?

The Hopkins & Allen XL No.8 was specifically designed to compete with high-end revolvers of its era, most notably the Colt Single Action Army (SAA) and the Smith & Wesson Model 3, aiming for the marshal's revolver market.

Why did the Hopkins & Allen XL No.8 fail commercially?

Despite its quality, the XL No.8 failed commercially because Hopkins & Allen was primarily known for inexpensive firearms. Customers were unwilling to pay a premium price for a revolver from a brand associated with 'Saturday Night Specials'.

What calibers were available for the Hopkins & Allen XL No.8?

The XL No.8 came in three versions: Army (.44 caliber), Navy (.38 caliber), and Police (.38 caliber). The Army model could be chambered in .44 Henry Rimfire or .44-40 Winchester Centerfire, while the Navy and Police models were rimfire only.

What design influences are visible on the Hopkins & Allen XL No.8?

The XL No.8 shows significant design influence from Merwin & Hulbert firearms, particularly in its grip shape and the style of the loading gate. However, it uses a more conventional manual extraction rod system.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Forgotten Weapons

View all →