M&P Shield Plus Review | SIG P365XL Comparison

Published on December 19, 2022
Duration: 27:37

This video provides a detailed comparison between the Smith & Wesson M&P Shield Plus and the SIG Sauer P365XL, focusing on their suitability for concealed carry. The review highlights differences in grip size, trigger quality, magazine capacity, and overall shooting experience. The presenters, experienced firearms users, offer insights into the practical aspects of each firearm, including potential drawbacks like magazine loading difficulties with the Shield Plus.

Quick Summary

The M&P Shield Plus offers a wider grip and an improved trigger with a predictable wall and crisp reset, making it a strong contender for concealed carry. While the SIG P365XL is slimmer, its grip can be tight, and magazine seating requires careful attention to ensure full engagement for reliable feeding.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Shoutout
  2. 00:06Review Introduction: M&P Shield Plus vs SIG P365XL
  3. 00:25Shoutout to Johnny's Coin Rings
  4. 01:07M&P Fan and History
  5. 01:44The Rise of High-Capacity Compacts
  6. 02:03Smith & Wesson M&P Shield Plus Introduction
  7. 02:21Size Comparison: Shield Plus vs. Springfield Hellcat
  8. 02:34Grip Width: The Key Difference
  9. 02:51Hand Size Comparison
  10. 03:17Trigger Reach and Grip Comfort
  11. 03:44Introducing the Original M&P Shield
  12. 04:05Original Shield vs. Shield Plus Comparison
  13. 04:39Magazine Interchangeability
  14. 04:50Magazine Capacity and Size
  15. 05:08Width Comparison: Original Shield vs. Shield Plus
  16. 05:34Shield Plus Capacity: 14 Round (13+1)
  17. 05:39Overall Size Comparison: Original Shield, P365XL, Shield Plus
  18. 06:00Grip Thickness and Barrel Length
  19. 06:12Kim's Thoughts on the SIG P365XL
  20. 06:38The Biggest Change: Capacity and Trigger
  21. 06:46Shield Plus Trigger: A Game Changer
  22. 06:53Evolution of M&P Triggers
  23. 07:24Shield Plus Trigger vs. M&P 2.0
  24. 07:57Shield Plus Trigger: A Different Animal
  25. 08:03Up Close: Trigger Characteristics
  26. 08:12Trigger Comparison: Shield Plus vs. Original
  27. 08:33SIG P365XL Trigger
  28. 08:37Why the Shield Plus Trigger is Loved
  29. 08:57Old Trigger vs. New Trigger Feel
  30. 09:22Performance Center Sights
  31. 09:30Sight Preferences: Front vs. Rear
  32. 09:58Complaint with Original M&P: No Combat Edge
  33. 10:13One-Handed Manipulation
  34. 10:22Magazine Release Improvement
  35. 10:34Slide Lock/Release
  36. 10:40Takedown Procedure
  37. 11:15Grip Texture Improvement
  38. 11:44Four-Inch Model Grip Purchase
  39. 12:08Grip Comparison: Shield Plus vs. P365XL
  40. 12:21P365XL Stippling
  41. 12:35Original Grip Texture
  42. 12:45SIG X-Ray Sights
  43. 13:00Holster Recommendation: Veterans Set Us Up
  44. 13:36Big Disappointment: Magazine Loading
  45. 13:43Magazine Issues: Tightness and Failure
  46. 14:33Contacting Smith & Wesson
  47. 14:53Replacement Magazine Issues
  48. 15:05Reviewing Online Feedback
  49. 15:12Student Experiences with Tight Mags
  50. 15:26Another Magazine Experience
  51. 15:39Unresolved Magazine Tightness
  52. 16:03Overall Reliability Outside of Mags
  53. 16:09Recommendation: Four-Inch Shield Plus
  54. 16:16Considering the SIG P365XL
  55. 16:21Issue with SIG P365XL: Magazine Seating
  56. 16:36SIG P365XL Magazine Seating Demonstration
  57. 16:52Range Time: Loading Magazines
  58. 17:04Loading Shield Plus 13-Round Magazines
  59. 17:34Difficulty Loading 13th Round
  60. 18:05Second Magazine Loading Attempt
  61. 18:44Using a Magazine Loader
  62. 19:51Testing the Most Effective Magazine
  63. 20:08Shooting with a Difficult Magazine
  64. 20:39Magazine Drop Free Test
  65. 21:01Trusting the Magazine for Carry
  66. 21:18Testing a Magazine that Took 13 Rounds
  67. 21:31Manual Cycling Test
  68. 21:41Shooting Impressions: Shield Plus
  69. 22:07Malfunction with Magazine Pressure
  70. 22:30Another Magazine Ran Fine
  71. 22:35Seven Yard Accuracy Test
  72. 23:09Accuracy Results
  73. 23:27Speeding Up: Reload Drill
  74. 23:39Reloading with Shield Plus
  75. 24:15Malfunction Training Drill
  76. 25:48Kim's Shooting Impressions: Shield Plus vs. SIG
  77. 26:09Back to the Shield Plus
  78. 26:18Kim's Thoughts on Shield Plus Trigger and Grip
  79. 26:40SIG P365XL Magazine Seating Reminder
  80. 26:59Conclusion and Wrap-up
  81. 27:09Final Thoughts and Recommendations
  82. 27:16Call to Action: Like, Sub, Share
  83. 27:22Social Media and Patreon

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the Smith & Wesson M&P Shield Plus and the SIG Sauer P365XL for concealed carry?

The M&P Shield Plus offers a wider grip, which can be more comfortable for larger hands, and features an improved trigger. The SIG P365XL is slimmer and more compact, but its grip can be tight for some, and magazine seating requires extra attention to ensure it's fully engaged.

How does the trigger on the M&P Shield Plus compare to previous M&P models?

The M&P Shield Plus trigger is considered a significant upgrade, described as a 'game changer' with a predictable wall, smooth brake, and crisp reset. This is a notable improvement over the hinged and sometimes mushy triggers found on older M&P generations.

Are there any common issues reported with the M&P Shield Plus magazines?

Some users have reported issues with the 13-round magazines for the M&P Shield Plus being excessively tight, making manual loading difficult and, in rare cases, leading to magazine failure. However, this is not a universal problem, and many users experience no such issues.

Which handgun is better for concealed carry: the M&P Shield Plus or the SIG P365XL?

The choice depends on individual preference and hand size. The Shield Plus offers a more substantial grip and a superior trigger, while the P365XL is slimmer for easier concealment. Both are accurate and reliable, but the Shield Plus's grip width may be more comfortable for some shooters.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Geauga Firearms Academy

View all →