Magnum Research 1911 Commander vs Devil Dog Arms Commander 1911 (Both 1911's have cast frames)

Published on October 14, 2019
Duration: 19:33

This expert-level comparison by BERETTA9mmUSA analyzes the Magnum Research Desert Eagle 1911C against the Devil Dog Arms 1911 Commander. The review highlights differences in machining quality, barrel systems (bull vs. bushing), checkering, and trigger pull, concluding that the Magnum Research model offers superior fit, finish, and features for a lower price, despite both utilizing cast frames and Series 70 designs.

Quick Summary

The Magnum Research Desert Eagle 1911C offers superior value over the Devil Dog Arms 1911 Commander due to better machining, fit, and finish, despite both using cast frames and Series 70 designs. The Magnum Research model features a bull barrel, full-length guide rod, and a lighter trigger pull (approx. 4.25 lbs) compared to the DDA's bushing barrel and 5 lb trigger.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: 1911 Commander Comparison
  2. 00:52Technical Overview: Series 70 Design
  3. 01:52Sponsor: Kore Essentials Gun Belts
  4. 05:17Machining & Fitment Analysis
  5. 09:33Front Strap Checkering Comparison
  6. 11:32Guide Rod & Barrel Systems
  7. 13:18Sights & Finishes
  8. 14:50Magazines & Trigger Pull
  9. 15:46Price & Final Verdict

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the Magnum Research Desert Eagle 1911C and the Devil Dog Arms 1911 Commander?

The Magnum Research 1911C features a bull barrel with a full-length guide rod and superior machining/fitment, while the Devil Dog Arms 1911 uses a traditional bushing barrel with a GI-style guide rod and exhibits more casting imperfections. Both are Series 70 designs with cast frames.

Which 1911 pistol offers better value for money in this comparison?

The Magnum Research Desert Eagle 1911C is considered to offer better value. It has a lower MSRP, superior fit and finish, a better trigger pull (4.25 lbs vs 5 lbs), and a more modern barrel system compared to the Devil Dog Arms 1911.

What type of frame construction do these Commander 1911 pistols use?

Both the Magnum Research Desert Eagle 1911C and the Devil Dog Arms 1911 Commander utilize precision cast frames. This manufacturing method is common for cost-effectiveness but requires careful finishing to achieve high-quality fit and appearance.

How do the trigger pulls compare on the Magnum Research and Devil Dog Arms 1911s?

The Magnum Research 1911C has a lighter and reportedly better trigger pull, averaging around 4.25 lbs. The Devil Dog Arms 1911 trigger pull is heavier, averaging 5 lbs. Both models are Series 70 designs, which typically results in a cleaner trigger break.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from BERETTA9mmUSA

View all →