My most expensive rifle at the range- Underwood M1 carbine, U.S. 30 cal

Published on October 8, 2025
Duration: 7:31

This video reviews the Underwood M1 Carbine, highlighting its value as a military re-arsenal firearm despite a high purchase price of $1,700. The reviewer emphasizes its reliability, lightweight design, and light recoil, making it enjoyable for plinking. Ammunition cost and magazine reliability are discussed, with a preference for older, well-maintained magazines over newer ones.

Quick Summary

The Underwood M1 Carbine is a military re-arsenal firearm costing $1,700, valued for its matching serial numbers and condition. It's praised for being lightweight, accurate, and having light recoil, making it ideal for plinking. While generally reliable, magazine quality can vary, with older military magazines often outperforming newer ones.

Chapters

  1. 00:48Introduction: Most Expensive Rifle
  2. 01:00Underwood M1 Carbine Price and Value
  3. 01:18Military Re-arsenal Features
  4. 01:36Initial Range Performance
  5. 01:46Plinking with Winchester Ammo
  6. 01:5430 Carbine Ammunition Cost
  7. 02:11Reloading Ammunition
  8. 02:20Rifle Characteristics: Lightweight, Accurate, Reliable
  9. 02:56Encountering a Magazine Hiccup
  10. 03:55Magazine Functionality Issues
  11. 04:08New vs. Old Magazines
  12. 04:33Identifying an Original M1 Carbine Magazine
  13. 05:18Eminence Reloads Ammunition
  14. 05:33Reloading Eminence Reloads Brass
  15. 05:52Testing Problematic Magazine Again
  16. 06:01The Joy of Range Time
  17. 06:41Final Shots and Outro

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Underwood M1 Carbine and why is it considered expensive?

The Underwood M1 Carbine is a military re-arsenal firearm where all serial numbers match. The reviewer paid $1,700 for it, which is significantly higher than commercially made versions, due to its historical authenticity and condition.

How reliable is the M1 Carbine according to the reviewer?

The reviewer initially found the M1 Carbine to be extremely reliable, shooting 200 rounds without a single hiccup. However, a later issue with a new manufacturer magazine caused one hiccup, though older magazines performed well.

What are the key characteristics of the M1 Carbine that make it enjoyable to shoot?

The M1 Carbine is praised for being super lightweight, light shooting, and having light recoil. It is also described as very accurate and reliable, making it a favorite for plinking.

What is the cost of 30 Carbine ammunition, and what are the alternatives?

30 Carbine ammunition can be expensive, often costing $35-$40 for 50 rounds, and sometimes reaching $1 per round. Reloading this ammunition is a cost-effective alternative, with Eminence Reloads and Starline brass being recommended.

What advice is given regarding M1 Carbine magazines?

The reviewer suggests that older, original military magazines, even if rusty, can be made reliable with proper maintenance. Newer manufactured magazines can be hit-or-miss, with some not functioning as well as the originals.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Cranky Gun Reviews

View all →