S&W Model 19 Classic vs Original

Published on August 1, 2019
Duration: 28:04

This video provides an expert comparison between the original Smith & Wesson Model 19-3 and the modern Model 19-9 Classic, hosted by firearms authority Hickok45. Key differences in design, manufacturing, and performance are detailed, offering valuable insights for enthusiasts and potential buyers of classic or modern K-frame revolvers.

Quick Summary

Hickok45 highlights critical differences between the S&W Model 19-9 Classic and the original Model 19-3, focusing on the reinforced round forcing cone of the Classic model which prevents cracking under heavy .357 Magnum loads, unlike the 'flat spot' design on older K-frames. He also notes the Classic's ball detent lockup and sleeved barrel.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Model Identification
  2. 02:31Visual and Frame Comparison
  3. 03:23Technical Design Changes
  4. 06:00Range Performance: .357 Magnum
  5. 10:00Barrel Construction and Weight
  6. 11:00Controversial Modern Features
  7. 12:40Frame and Grip Differences
  8. 15:10Manufacturing Realities

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key design differences between the S&W Model 19-9 Classic and the original Model 19-3?

The Model 19-9 Classic features a reinforced, round forcing cone to prevent cracking under heavy .357 Magnum loads, a ball detent cylinder lockup, and a 4.25-inch sleeved barrel. The original Model 19-3 has a forcing cone with a 'flat spot', a traditional solid barrel, and lacks the ball detent lockup.

How does the barrel construction differ between the S&W Model 19 Classic and its original counterpart?

The modern S&W Model 19-9 Classic utilizes a 4.25-inch sleeved barrel, which consists of an inner stainless steel tube within an outer shroud. This contrasts with the original Model 19-3's traditional 4-inch solid barrel construction.

What are the common criticisms of modern S&W revolvers like the Model 19-9 Classic?

Purists often criticize modern S&W revolvers for features such as the internal key lock (the 'Hillary Hole'), the use of frame-mounted firing pins instead of hammer-mounted ones, and the incorporation of Metal Injection Molded (MIM) parts for components like the trigger and hammer.

Why did S&W stop producing revolvers exactly like the original Model 19?

According to Hickok45, S&W likely cannot replicate the original Model 19 exactly due to the loss of specific machining tools, specialized labor skills required for traditional hand-fitting, and the prohibitive cost of such methods in modern mass production.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from hickok45

View all →