S&W Shield Plus vs S&W CSX: Which One Is Actually Better?

Published on June 27, 2022
Duration: 9:15

This expert review from Honest Outlaw provides a critical, objective comparison between the Smith & Wesson Shield Plus and CSX, two popular 9mm micro-compact pistols for concealed carry. The review highlights significant differences in trigger performance, reliability (specifically the CSX's 'trigger freeze' issue), and aftermarket support, ultimately declaring the Shield Plus the superior option for most users due to its better accuracy, faster follow-up shots, and wider accessory availability. The assessment is driven by extensive range time and detailed technical analysis.

Quick Summary

The S&W Shield Plus is recommended over the CSX for concealed carry due to its superior trigger (6 lbs, crisp reset), better reliability (no 'trigger freeze' issues), and extensive aftermarket support. The CSX, while hammer-fired, suffers from a heavier trigger (7.5 lbs, long reset) and demonstrated malfunctions during rapid fire testing.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and Comparison Overview
  2. 01:19S&W Shield Plus Specifications
  3. 02:11S&W CSX Specifications
  4. 03:44Shooting Performance and Trigger Analysis
  5. 05:11Aftermarket Support and Holsters
  6. 06:56Reliability and 'Trigger Freeze' Issues
  7. 08:38Final Verdict

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the S&W Shield Plus and CSX?

The Shield Plus is a striker-fired pistol with a polymer frame and a crisp trigger reset, known for its reliability and extensive aftermarket support. The CSX is a hammer-fired pistol with an aluminum frame, featuring a manual safety but suffering from a longer trigger reset and a 'trigger freeze' reliability issue.

Which pistol is more reliable, the Shield Plus or the CSX?

The S&W Shield Plus is considered more reliable. The CSX experienced 'trigger freeze' during testing, where the trigger failed to reset properly during rapid fire, leading to malfunctions. The Shield Plus demonstrated consistent reliability.

How does the aftermarket support compare for the Shield Plus and CSX?

The S&W Shield Plus boasts significantly better aftermarket support, with a wide availability of holsters, magazines, sights, and other accessories. The S&W CSX currently has very limited aftermarket options, making customization more challenging.

Which pistol is recommended for concealed carry between the Shield Plus and CSX?

Based on expert assessment, the S&W Shield Plus is the recommended choice for most concealed carry users due to its superior trigger, proven reliability, better accuracy, faster follow-up shots, and extensive aftermarket support, offering better overall value and performance.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from Honest Outlaw

View all →