S&W Shield's Deadly Flaw

Published on August 15, 2013
Duration: 4:56

This review highlights a critical flaw in the Smith & Wesson M&P Shield's manual safety, which can engage unintentionally during carry, potentially hindering a defensive situation. Despite this significant safety concern, the reviewer praises the pistol's comfortable grip, comparing it favorably to competitors like the Springfield XDS and Sig P290. The analysis suggests a version without the manual safety might be preferable for concealed carry.

Quick Summary

The S&W M&P Shield has a critical flaw where its manual safety can engage unintentionally during concealed carry due to friction. This is dangerous for self-defense as it can prevent the firearm from being ready when needed, and it requires more pressure to disengage than to engage.

Chapters

  1. 00:20Introduction to the S&W Shield
  2. 01:29The 'Deadly Flaw': Safety Engagement
  3. 02:42Self-Defense Implications of Safety Flaw
  4. 03:35Grip Comparisons & Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main flaw discussed regarding the S&W M&P Shield?

The primary flaw identified is the manual safety lever's tendency to engage unintentionally during concealed carry. This can happen due to friction from holsters or bags, potentially making the firearm inoperable when needed.

Why is the Shield's safety engagement issue considered dangerous for self-defense?

It's dangerous because a concealed carry firearm must be instantly ready. If the safety accidentally engages itself, the user might expect the gun to fire but find it disabled, which could be fatal in a defensive encounter.

How does the S&W Shield's manual safety compare to its activation pressure?

The reviewer notes that it actually requires more deliberate pressure to disengage the Shield's manual safety than it does to activate it. This makes accidental engagement a significant concern.

What positive aspects of the S&W Shield are mentioned despite the safety flaw?

Despite the safety issue, the reviewer praises the Shield's grip ergonomics, finding it comfortable and favorably comparing it to other subcompact pistols like the Springfield XDS and Sig P290.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →