Sbardella Arms Full Stroke Commander 1911 vs. Cabot Guns NS Commander 1911

Published on February 10, 2024
Duration: 26:55

This video compares the Sbardella Arms Full Stroke Commander 1911 and the Cabot Guns National Standard Commander 1911, highlighting differences in build quality, materials, and features. The Sbardella Arms model is praised for its all-forged parts, meticulous finishing, and reliable operation, while the Cabot Guns model, despite its aesthetic appeal, experienced significant reliability issues and had a concerning ambidextrous safety engagement problem. The discussion emphasizes the value of high-quality components and craftsmanship in custom 1911s.

Quick Summary

The Sbardella Arms Full Stroke Commander 1911 is praised for its all-forged steel construction, enhanced 'full stroke' reliability design, and flawless operation, offering superior value. The Cabot Guns National Standard Commander, while aesthetically pleasing, suffered from initial inoperability and a problematic ambidextrous safety that could engage unintentionally.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Custom 1911s
  2. 00:11Cabot Guns National Standard Commander Overview
  3. 00:17Sbardella Arms Full Stroke Commander Overview
  4. 00:30Cabot Guns Reliability Issues
  5. 00:35MIM vs. Forged Parts Discussion
  6. 01:14Les Baer Parts Durability
  7. 01:26Glock Durability Comparison
  8. 02:07Handgun Caliber Recommendations
  9. 02:30Commander Size Explained
  10. 02:44Sbardella Full Stroke Design
  11. 03:18Cabot Gun Inoperable on Arrival
  12. 03:47Cabot Gun Features: Sights & Serrations
  13. 03:53Sbardella Arms Features: Snag-Free Design
  14. 04:03Sbardella Gun Details: Sights & Safety
  15. 04:48Ambi Safety Design Comparison
  16. 05:00Grip and Finish Comparison
  17. 05:31Trigger and Grip Safety Interaction
  18. 05:51Weight and Frame Material
  19. 06:26Trigger Pull and Feel
  20. 07:35Trigger Pull Weight Measurements
  21. 08:53Accidental Safety Engagement Issue
  22. 11:11Dan Wesson Vigil Safety Comparison
  23. 13:00Cabot Gun Customer Service Issues
  24. 13:20Safety Engagement Concern Validity
  25. 14:08Sbardella Arms Overall Quality
  26. 14:12Sbardella Arms Pricing & Value
  27. 15:08Cabot Gun Trigger Design
  28. 15:20Ambi Safety Tension Comparison
  29. 15:42Sbardella Standard vs. Custom Finishes
  30. 16:10Sbardella Feed Ramp & Guide Rod
  31. 16:34Ambi Safety for Left-Handed Shooters
  32. 16:59Slide-to-Frame Fit and Extractor Tuning
  33. 17:18Blended Backstrap and Grip Safety
  34. 18:16Detailed Pistol Comparison
  35. 18:20Cabot Guns Stainless Steel Construction
  36. 18:36Cabot Guns Cosmetics vs. Functionality
  37. 18:51Manufacturer Reputation: Cabot vs. Sbardella
  38. 19:00Sbardella Arms Company Background
  39. 19:39Final Thoughts: Customer Experience
  40. 19:53Sbardella Arms Customer Service
  41. 20:01Goal of a High-Quality Firearm
  42. 20:08Bang for Your Buck: Sbardella vs. Cabot
  43. 20:34Sbardella Ledge Sight Functionality
  44. 20:43Safety Lever Tension Comparison
  45. 20:48Match Gray Barrels
  46. 21:11Overall Fit and Finish
  47. 21:17Grip and Checkering Details
  48. 21:39Sbardella Grip Safety Interface
  49. 22:12Exclusivity vs. Popularity
  50. 22:32Sbardella: The Worker Gun
  51. 22:56Sbardella Trigger Pull Weight
  52. 23:21Final Comparison: Cabot vs. Sbardella
  53. 23:33Cabot High Gloss Blueing
  54. 23:45Selling Cabot Guns
  55. 24:23Cabot Grand Torino vs. National Standard
  56. 25:01Caliber Options (45 ACP, 9mm, 38 Super)
  57. 25:23Other 1911 Buyer's Guides
  58. 25:38Les Baer Custom 1911s
  59. 26:01Budget 1911 Options (Springfield, Taurus)
  60. 26:28Conclusion and Channel Outro

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key differences between the Sbardella Arms Full Stroke Commander and the Cabot Guns National Standard Commander?

The Sbardella Arms Commander features all forged steel parts, a 'full stroke' design for enhanced reliability, meticulous hand-fitting, and flawless operation. The Cabot Guns Commander, while aesthetically pleasing, experienced significant initial reliability issues and had a concerning tendency for its ambidextrous safety to engage unintentionally.

Why is the 'full stroke' design important in a Commander 1911?

A 'full stroke' or 'full cycle' design extends the slide's travel to match that of a 5-inch 1911. This modification aims to improve ejection consistency and overall reliability, offering a smoother operation compared to traditional Commander models with shorter slide travel.

What issues were reported with the Cabot Guns National Standard Commander?

The Cabot Guns National Standard Commander was reported to be inoperable upon arrival, requiring extensive work to become functional. Additionally, its ambidextrous safety was found to engage unintentionally under certain grip pressures, posing a potential safety concern.

How does the material quality compare between Sbardella Arms and Cabot Guns 1911s?

Sbardella Arms emphasizes using all forged steel parts for extreme durability, a hallmark of high-end custom firearms. In contrast, while Cabot Guns produces visually appealing pistols, the discussion notes that even premium brands like Les Baer may use some MIM or cast parts, and the Cabot model's issues suggest potential inconsistencies in material application or quality control.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from BERETTA9mmUSA

View all →