Shotgun Vs Intruder - What really works??

Published on May 14, 2025
Duration: 11:26

This video evaluates four shotguns for home defense: the Beretta A300 Ultima, Mossberg Chainsaw, Gen 12 PDW, and Taurus Judge Home Defender. The presenter assesses spread patterns and damage output at various distances using paper targets and watermelons, highlighting the effectiveness of 12-gauge options for stopping power while noting limitations of the .410 Judge for home defense at typical engagement ranges.

Quick Summary

For home defense, 12-gauge shotguns like the Beretta A300 Ultima and Mossberg Chainsaw offer significant stopping power. The Gen 12 PDW is also effective, especially with buckshot, due to its compact size and recoil management. The .410 Taurus Judge is generally considered less effective at typical home defense distances.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction: Best Home Defense Shotguns
  2. 00:21Shotgun Option 1: Gen 12 PDW
  3. 00:34Shotgun Option 2: Beretta A300 Ultima
  4. 00:45Shotgun Option 3: Mossberg Chainsaw
  5. 00:59Shotgun Option 4: Judge Home Defender (.410)
  6. 01:07Testing Methodology: Spread and Damage
  7. 01:46Beretta A300 Ultima: Spread and Kick Analysis
  8. 02:39A300 Ultima Spread Test Results
  9. 02:54Mossberg Chainsaw: Design and Spread
  10. 03:28Chainsaw Spread Test Results
  11. 04:22Gen 12 PDW: Short Barrel, Suppressed, Magazine Fed
  12. 04:51Gen 12 PDW Spread Test Results
  13. 06:01Taurus Judge Home Defender: .410 Bore Test
  14. 06:38Judge Home Defender Spread Test Results
  15. 07:25Damage Test Setup: Watermelons
  16. 07:43Damage Test: Taurus Judge Home Defender (.410)
  17. 08:24Damage Test: Gen 12 PDW (12 Gauge)
  18. 09:25Damage Test: Mossberg Chainsaw (12 Gauge)
  19. 10:07Damage Test: Beretta A300 Ultima (12 Gauge)
  20. 10:41Conclusion: Which Shotgun to Pick?

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best shotguns for home defense?

For home defense, 12-gauge shotguns like the Beretta A300 Ultima and Mossberg Chainsaw offer significant stopping power. The Gen 12 PDW is also effective, especially with buckshot, due to its compact size and recoil management. The .410 Taurus Judge is generally considered less effective at typical home defense distances.

How does shotgun spread affect home defense effectiveness?

Shotgun spread is crucial for home defense. A tighter spread, like that from the Beretta A300 Ultima, allows for more precise targeting, while excessively wide spreads, seen with the .410 Judge, can reduce damage output and make it difficult to hit a specific target effectively at range.

What is the damage output of a 12-gauge shotgun for home defense?

12-gauge shotguns, particularly with buckshot, deliver substantial damage capable of incapacitating threats. Tests show they can completely disintegrate targets like watermelons at 15 feet, indicating sufficient power for home defense scenarios.

Are short-barreled shotguns good for home defense?

Short-barreled shotguns like the Gen 12 PDW can be advantageous for maneuverability in tight spaces. However, their effectiveness can be influenced by ammunition type and the presence of suppressors or muzzle devices that manage recoil and spread.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from PewPewDingers

View all →