Staccato P Limited / Rock Island Double Stack Comparison

Published on September 7, 2022
Duration: 12:02

This video provides a side-by-side comparison of the Staccato P and a Rock Island double-stack 9mm pistol. The reviewer, a self-proclaimed 'regular gun guy' rather than a competition shooter, highlights key differences in price, grip texture, trigger guard design, slide serrations, sights, and magazine quality. While acknowledging the Staccato's premium features and feel, the reviewer notes the Rock Island's surprisingly smooth slide and competitive price point, suggesting it's a viable option for those on a budget. Both firearms are tested for recoil and accuracy at 7 yards, with the reviewer expressing surprise at achieving a tighter group with the Rock Island in one instance.

Quick Summary

The Staccato P and Rock Island double stack 9mm pistols offer distinct value propositions. The Staccato P, at around $3100, boasts premium features like aggressive grip texturing, refined slide serrations, and suppressor height sights. The Rock Island, priced at approximately $750, provides a solid, functional firearm with a surprisingly smooth slide and a full Picatinny rail, making it a budget-friendly alternative.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Intro and Channel Welcome
  2. 00:46Comparison Overview
  3. 01:56Visual Differences
  4. 02:15Price Comparison
  5. 02:46Grip Comparison
  6. 03:17Trigger Guard Comparison
  7. 03:50Slide Comparison
  8. 04:20Sights Comparison
  9. 04:39Slide Smoothness Test
  10. 05:22Magazine Comparison
  11. 05:48Market Positioning
  12. 06:01Accessory Rails
  13. 06:18Trigger Test
  14. 07:27Customization Note
  15. 07:32Shooting Test Setup
  16. 08:26Staccato P Shooting Results
  17. 08:55Rock Island Shooting Results
  18. 09:38Downrange Target Review
  19. 10:15Feel and Shooting Impressions
  20. 10:40Conclusion and Recommendation
  21. 11:36Is it a Staccato Alternative?

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main difference in price between the Staccato P and the Rock Island double stack 9mm?

The Staccato P is significantly more expensive, retailing for around $3100, while the Rock Island double stack 9mm is priced much lower at approximately $750. This price difference is a major factor in their market positioning.

How do the grips and trigger guards compare on the Staccato P and Rock Island?

The Staccato P features a more detailed and aggressive grip texture for better purchase. Its trigger guard is also more spacious and includes stippling, offering a more refined design compared to the Rock Island's basic, rounded trigger guard.

What are the key differences in slide and sights between the two pistols?

Both pistols have front and rear slide serrations, but the Staccato P's are more refined. The Staccato P comes equipped with suppressor height sights, whereas the Rock Island has standard sights.

How does the trigger performance compare between the Staccato P and the Rock Island?

The reviewer found the Staccato P's trigger to have minimal take-up and a crisp reset, giving it a slight edge. The Rock Island's trigger also had little take-up and an audible reset, performing well for its price point.

Related News

All News →

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from A REGULAR GUN GUY

View all →