The Better Pocket Shotgun? Taurus Polymer Judge

Published on November 14, 2018
Duration: 18:21

This review of the Taurus Polymer Judge, presented by nutnfancy, offers a pragmatic assessment of its utility as a concealed carry firearm. The analysis covers its dual-caliber capability (.410 bore/.45 LC), lightweight polymer construction, and ergonomic considerations, while critically evaluating its build quality and shooting performance. The speaker, an established reviewer with extensive testing history, concludes it's a 'provisional yes' for specific roles like a 'snake gun' or vehicle defense, though he favors the Smith & Wesson Governor for superior quality.

Quick Summary

The Taurus Polymer Judge (4510PLYFS) is a lightweight, polymer-framed revolver weighing about 23 oz, capable of firing both .410 bore and .45 Long Colt. While versatile for close-range defense, its accuracy is fair, and build quality is criticized compared to steel alternatives.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Introduction and History of the Judge
  2. 01:00Review Context and Past Impressions
  3. 02:05Tabletop Gear Showcase (EDC Items)
  4. 05:58Taurus Polymer Public Defender Specs
  5. 07:03Build Quality and Aesthetics Critique
  6. 08:40Ergonomics and Controls Issues
  7. 10:40Trigger and Sights Evaluation
  8. 11:25Shooting Performance and Accuracy
  9. 12:46Final Verdict and Comparison

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key features of the Taurus Polymer Judge?

The Taurus Polymer Judge, model 4510PLYFS, is a polymer-framed revolver weighing around 23 oz with a 2-inch barrel. It's notable for its dual-caliber capability, firing both .410 bore shotgun shells and .45 Long Colt ammunition, making it a versatile option for self-defense.

How accurate is the Taurus Polymer Judge for self-defense?

Accuracy for the Taurus Polymer Judge is considered 'fair' at best, suitable for very close ranges, typically under 10 feet. It's best viewed as a 'pocket shotgun' for immediate defensive needs rather than a precision target pistol.

What are the ergonomic drawbacks of the Taurus Polymer Judge?

Criticisms include a 'bulky' frame that may hinder speedloader use, a cylinder release that could be improved, and comfortable 'ribber' grips that might snag on clothing during concealed carry draws.

Is the Taurus Polymer Judge recommended for concealed carry?

The reviewer gives a 'provisional yes' for specific users needing a lightweight, versatile firearm for roles like a 'snake gun' or vehicle defense. However, the perceived lower build quality compared to alternatives like the Smith & Wesson Governor is a consideration.

More Reviews Videos You Might Like

More from nutnfancy

View all →