Revolvers like this can suck for self defense.

Published on July 1, 2023
Duration: 1:01

This video argues that revolvers, particularly lightweight ones like the S&W 340PD, are often a poor choice for self-defense in 2023 compared to semi-automatic pistols. The speaker highlights the 340PD's painful recoil with .357 Magnum loads and debunks the myth of superior revolver reliability, citing internal spring failures and 'gauntlet tests'. For those preferring revolvers, 9mm is suggested over .357 Magnum.

Quick Summary

Lightweight revolvers like the S&W 340PD can be a poor self-defense choice due to painful recoil with .357 Magnum loads, often necessitating the use of weaker .38 Special. Reliability myths are also debunked, as internal springs can fail.

Chapters

  1. 00:00Revolvers vs. Autoloaders for Self Defense
  2. 00:12S&W 340PD Specs & Shootability Issues
  3. 00:28Debunking Revolver Reliability Myths
  4. 00:44Caliber Preference & Range Demo

Frequently Asked Questions

Are revolvers still good for self-defense in 2023?

While revolvers have traditional appeal, many experts now consider them less ideal for self-defense than modern semi-automatic pistols. Lightweight revolvers can be difficult to shoot accurately due to recoil, and claims of superior reliability are often debated.

What are the drawbacks of the Smith & Wesson 340PD for self-defense?

The S&W 340PD is extremely lightweight (11 oz) and expensive. While chambered in .357 Magnum, it's notoriously painful to shoot with full-power loads, often leading owners to use less potent .38 Special ammunition.

Are revolvers less reliable than semi-automatic pistols?

The notion that revolvers are inherently more reliable is often a myth. Revolvers have internal springs that can fail, and 'gauntlet tests' have shown semi-automatic pistols can sometimes withstand adverse conditions better than revolvers.

If I prefer a revolver, what caliber should I consider for self-defense?

If you are set on a revolver for self-defense, the speaker suggests considering 9mm over .357 Magnum. This is often due to better shootability and manageable recoil, making follow-up shots easier.

Related News

All News →

More Self Defense Videos You Might Like

More from Military Arms Channel

View all →