Why five‑shot .38 Specials are obsolete for carry

Published on February 13, 2026
Duration: 1:57

The Yankee Marshal argues that five-shot .38 Special revolvers are obsolete for self-defense carry, citing their lack of cost advantage over 9mm and inadequate performance compared to larger .357 Magnum revolvers. While acknowledging niche uses for derringers and smaller calibers like .32 and .380, the speaker emphasizes that modern options offer better value and effectiveness.

Quick Summary

Five-shot .38 Special revolvers are considered obsolete for self-defense carry because they are no longer cheaper than 9mm handguns and offer less effective performance. For those considering .357 Magnum, larger revolvers are recommended for better recoil management and durability. Smaller calibers like .32 and .380 ACP have niche uses due to their compact size.

Chapters

  1. 00:00.357 Magnum in Small Revolvers
  2. 00:22.38 Special Revolvers: Obsolete
  3. 01:36Derringers, .32s, .380s, and 9mms

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are five-shot .38 Special revolvers considered obsolete for self-defense?

Five-shot .38 Special revolvers are deemed obsolete because they are no longer cheaper than 9mm alternatives and offer less effective performance for self-defense compared to modern handguns or larger revolvers.

What are the advantages of carrying a .357 Magnum in a larger revolver?

Carrying a .357 Magnum in a larger revolver is recommended for better recoil management, which leads to improved shooter comfort, accuracy, and longevity of the firearm itself under heavy use.

Are there any valid uses for smaller caliber handguns like .32 or .380 ACP?

Yes, derringers and smaller caliber handguns like .32 ACP and .380 ACP have specific niche uses where their compact size is essential and other firearms may not be suitable or concealable.

How do five-shot .38 Specials compare to 9mm handguns for concealed carry?

The speaker argues that five-shot .38 Specials are not cheaper than 9mm handguns and are generally less effective for self-defense, making 9mm a more practical and modern choice for concealed carry.

More Self Defense Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →