9mm Revolvers are Completely Stupid! (Never Buy One Unless...)

Published on March 25, 2025
Duration: 6:56

The Yankee Marshal argues against using 9mm revolvers as primary carry firearms, citing significant disadvantages. He suggests that the only justifiable use for a semi-automatic caliber revolver is as a backup gun, specifically to utilize ammunition from a disabled primary semi-automatic pistol. For primary revolvers, he strongly recommends calibers like .357 Magnum, with options to shoot lighter loads like .38 Special for recoil management.

Quick Summary

The only practical reason to own a revolver chambered in a semi-automatic caliber like 9mm is for use as a backup gun. This allows you to utilize ammunition from a disabled primary semi-automatic pistol, ensuring you have more rounds available. For primary carry, .357 Magnum revolvers are recommended for their power and versatility, with options to shoot lighter .38 Special loads for recoil management.

Chapters

  1. 00:10Introduction: The Problem with 9mm Revolvers
  2. 00:37Why Semi-Auto Caliber Revolvers Are Generally Bad
  3. 01:11Example: Chiappa Rhino in .40 S&W
  4. 01:35The ONE Reason to Carry a 9mm Revolver: Backup Gun
  5. 02:11Scenario: Primary Gun Incapacitated
  6. 02:55Ammunition Compatibility with Backup Revolver
  7. 04:22When to Buy a .357 Magnum Revolver Instead
  8. 04:29Recoil Management: .38 Special and Lighter Loads
  9. 05:06Recommended Revolver Calibers (.357 Magnum and Above)
  10. 05:24Final Verdict: Never Buy a 9mm Revolver (Unless...)

Frequently Asked Questions

When is it acceptable to buy a 9mm revolver?

According to The Yankee Marshal, the only justifiable reason to own a revolver chambered in a semi-automatic caliber like 9mm is for use as a backup gun. This allows you to utilize ammunition from a disabled primary semi-automatic pistol, ensuring you have more rounds available in a critical situation.

Why are 9mm revolvers generally not recommended for primary carry?

9mm revolvers are generally not recommended for primary carry because they don't offer the same advantages as revolvers in their intended calibers, like .357 Magnum. They can be less powerful and efficient, and the primary benefit of a revolver is often lost when chambered in a caliber designed for semi-automatic actions.

What are the advantages of carrying a .357 Magnum revolver as a primary firearm?

Carrying a .357 Magnum revolver as a primary firearm provides significant advantages. It offers more power and versatility, and you can shoot lighter loads like .38 Special or Cowboy Loads to manage recoil, making it suitable for a wider range of shooters and situations.

How can ammunition be shared between a primary semi-automatic pistol and a backup revolver?

If your primary semi-automatic pistol becomes incapacitated, you can use its spare magazines to feed a backup revolver if it's chambered in the same caliber (e.g., 9mm or .40 S&W). This strategy ensures that your carried ammunition is not wasted and can be utilized by your backup firearm.

Related News

All News →

More Tactical & Gear Videos You Might Like

More from TheYankeeMarshal

View all →